Personally I think he could be used closer to Logan Ryan than Chung. He seems as physical and intelligent as Ryan. I am not convinced yet that he has enough acceleration and short area quickness to be as effective on slot blitzes ect. but that is because we have no tape on that.
Good point, and good post. I think his similarities to Logan Ryan is why he has played so much better than expected.
In 2015 the Patriot secondary was largely a smoothly functioning unit, with Butler and Ryan as the two top CBs and McCourty and Chung as safeties. As many posters have pointed out, Ryan was somewhat limited athletically (particularly speed-wise) but he was extremely intelligent and a good tackler, and of course he had a Vulcan mind-meld with fellow Rutgers alum McCourty.
However, I think BB became concerned with his secondary's play in the biggest games against big receivers. The Pats made 6'5" Chris Matthews look like an undiscovered superstar in the Seattle Super Bowl, and 6'2" Sanu and 6'3" Jones overpowered the Pats secondary in the Falcon Super Bowl.
As a result, I think that BB decided to make a concerted effort to bring in bigger CBs. He drafted Cyrus Jones as a tough thick CB (although not tall), and when Jones struggled he traded for Rowe, a big CB who rotated with Ryan. This offseason, he let athletically limited (although intelligent and tough) Ryan go and surprised everyone by paying a bundle to the much taller and athletically gifted Gilmore. Finally, he traded for Bademosi, an intelligent, good tackling CB like Ryan, but much bigger (although much less experienced at CB).
So what happens? In the first few games without Ryan, the Patriot secondary looks completely discombobulated with terrible communication and nobody in the right place at the right time. Gilmore has never played with a cerebral defense like the Patriots and he seems flummoxed, Butler seems uncomfortable with his role and doesn't seem confident, and McCourty doesn't have Ryan reading his mind and vice versa. I would argue that some growing pains should have been expected.
Gilmore goes out, and Butler becomes the clear #1 CB, Bademosi substitutes into the Ryan role as a smart, great tackling CB, and suddenly the secondary appears to be much improved, being in the right place and communicating much better.
Does that mean that the secondary is better without Gilmore and Rowe (as some posters have suggested)? Almost surely not, Gilmore played well against Mike Evans, and hopefully he will get more and more familiar with his new teammates. BB makes mistakes, but if the secondary is better without Gilmore it would be one of his biggest goofs ever. I am very hopeful that the Patriot secondary becomes a real strength for the defense in another few weeks, as was originally anticipated.