Do Patriot fans have less loyalty to Tom Brady than Browns fans did to Bernie Kosar

[convertedpatsfan]

This is STILL going???

 

[dafoe2016]

If all you want is an above average QB and you trust BBs judgment why wouldn't you believe he will replace the GOAT with a different above average QB when it's time?
You say you trust his judgment then imply he will put the worst QB in the world out there if it isn't jimmy.

5 years of Brady is better than the careers of almost any active NFL QB.

No, I didn't imply any such thing. Most QBs drafted into the NFL are below average. Even ones who go high in the draft. Odds are, whomever Bill drafts isn't going to be all that good. Trusting Bill's judgement about roster players and his ability to judge a college player on another team are two drastically different things. Bill doesn't have some sort of super power that allows him to draft above average QBs on a whim. He is facing the same conundrum all QB needy team are facing if Brady and JG are gone. You might as well say somebody should throw away a winning lottery ticket because they could just win again later.

 

[Ring 6]

No, I didn't imply any such thing. Most QBs drafted into the NFL are below average. Even ones who go high in the draft. Odds are, whomever Bill drafts isn't going to be all that good. Trusting Bill's judgement about roster players and his ability to judge a college player on another team are two drastically different things. Bill doesn't have some sort of super power that allows him to draft above average QBs on a whim. He is facing the same conundrum all QB needy team are facing if Brady and JG are gone. You might as well say somebody should throw away a winning lottery ticket because they could just win again later.

You have had the winning lottery ticket all along. It's the one you wabt to throw away for a guy who has played 6 quarters.

 

[Tunescribe]

Lesson 3, quoting someone when you have nothing to interject into the conversation.

But, don't you know: remembering Kosar in relation to Brady is VERY important when it comes to playing an allegorical chess game with Death to determine once and for all whether Tom is a football immortal who represents winning the lottery or simply has delayed the inevitable by dining on avocado ice cream. Brady himself has split a lot of hairs in the process by changing hairstyles over the years per Gisele's urging while Garoppolo bides his time, ostensibly open to all options. Kosar, meanwhile, could not care less about a thread that most of the civilized world believes was meant from the get-go for this website's Practice Squad forum. Carry on.

 

[XLIX]

No, I didn't imply any such thing. Most QBs drafted into the NFL are below average.

I am not sure I agree with that, although it pretty much depends on how you define "average QB". Since many/most teams have 3 QB's, by definition, the "average" QB is the first backup.

Even ones who go high in the draft. Odds are, whomever Bill drafts isn't going to be all that good. Trusting Bill's judgement about roster players and his ability to judge a college player on another team are two drastically different things. Bill doesn't have some sort of super power that allows him to draft above average QBs on a whim. He is facing the same conundrum all QB needy team are facing if Brady and JG are gone. You might as well say somebody should throw away a winning lottery ticket because they could just win again later.

I guess I have more faith in Belichick's drafting abilities than you do.

 

[Galeb]

 

[Ring 6]

I am not sure I agree with that, although it pretty much depends on how you define "average QB". Since many/most teams have 3 QB's, by definition, the "average" QB is the first backup.
I guess I have more faith in Belichick's drafting abilities than you do.

Come on dude. Garoppolo is the greatest because BB drafted him and didn't trade him. So of course BB sucks at drafting QBs. Duh

 

[AzPatsFan]

He played the greatest SB game ever by a QB.

No he played the best 4th quarter and OT ever. He was terrible for most of three quarters.

 

[Ring 6]

No he played the best 4th quarter and OT ever. He was terrible for most of three quarters.

Terrible is moronic, but all together he played the greatest game by a QB in SB history.

 

[Jackson 2]

No he played the best 4th quarter and OT ever. He was terrible for most of three quarters.

BS. He moved the team up and down the field, only to be foiled by turnovers, the biggest of which was his fault. But, if you watch the replay of that game, and it's readily available, you'll see his receivers had a bunch of drops they normally catch. This notion that Brady sucked for three quarters is urban legend crap.

 

[sb1]

No he played the best 4th quarter and OT ever. He was terrible for most of three quarters.

Nah. He wasn't any more "terrible" than he was in both Giants games. Wasn't helped by drops and a fumble. The INT was on him but that's about it.

 

[RayClay]

So the patriots should get rid of Brady while he is still playing at a high level because someday he will die?

Talking to yourself now? I'm not in favor of Brady retiring anytime soon and you won't find that from me anywhere in this thread.

 

[Ring 6]

Talking to yourself now? I'm not in favor of Brady retiring anytime soon and you won't find that from me anywhere in this thread.

Then why are you posting this crap?

 

[dafoe2016]

You have had the winning lottery ticket all along. It's the one you wabt to throw away for a guy who has played 6 quarters.

Please point out any thread in which I said that we should get rid of Brady. Just one.

 

[dafoe2016]

I am not sure I agree with that, although it pretty much depends on how you define "average QB". Since many/most teams have 3 QB's, by definition, the "average" QB is the first backup.
I guess I have more faith in Belichick's drafting abilities than you do.

No, I don't think you do. There are very few QBs that come out of college who are above average. There are even fewer who are available outside of the top ten picks. Without bottoming out after Brady and JG leave the Patriots aren't sniffing any of those draft slots. So Bill, in this hypothetical situation, would be tasked with finding an above average QB in the middle of the first round or later. That is a very difficult task for any GM. Even a great one. Bill is not supernatural. He doesn't have magical powers. Reality will not suspend itself because Bill needs a QB. He can't just pluck one out of the draft like it's no big deal. That doesn't make him a bad GM. it's just reality.

 

[luuked]

No he played the best 4th quarter and OT ever. He was terrible for most of three quarters.

 

[RayClay]

Then why are you posting this crap?

I'm mocking a thread that compare Brady to Bernie Kosar and seems to be looking for fans to sign loyalty oaths.

 

[RayClay]

No, I don't think you do. There are very few QBs that come out of college who are above average.

Are you Garrison Keiller?

 

[RayClay]

I'm mocking a thread that compare Brady to Bernie Kosar and seems to be looking for fans to sign loyalty oaths.

With Brady reaching forty, it's logical for fans to bring up the possibility of succession. I don't happen to agree with them, but to say anyone that mentions the possibility is disloyal is stupid. Actually, the fans who were undyingly loyal to Kosar, not even close to Brady, were stupid.

Brady has played some of his best ball late in his career which is unusual, but it doesn't mean he might not have a swift decline, because he is a mortal human being.

A lot of nuance in their Andy. I know that's not your thing, but you might consider their are multiple valid points of view on this situation. I trust BB and I think he doesn't know what he will do yet.

 

[Ring 6]

Please point out any thread in which I said that we should get rid of Brady. Just one.

Perhaps I misunderstood your position.
So after 2017, assuming Brady plays about as he did in 2016, and now JAG wants to be a starter. You can't tag him and keep him because you can't afford it. So why do you do? Get rid of JAG or get rid of Brady?