God, people don't get why a GOAT is a GOAT.
It ain't how many yards you pass, though it's not a bad idea to have a lot of passing yardage. Otherwise Brees would be the GOAT.
It ain't how many TDs you throw, although you really should have a lot of those too. Otherwise, Peyton Manning would be the GOAT.
The really big deal is winning a lot of ****. Then doing it with whole other crews of linemen, receivers, etc., in the modern era. It's being the best ever, and the guy who throws for 500 yds and 5 TDs in as losing effort is just seldom thought to have won a shootout against a guy with 400 yards and 4 TDs.
WINNING ALL THE FREAKING TIME COUNTS.
Call me when it's almost a 50-50 shot that Rodgers will be in a Super Bowl - not by Vegas odds, statistically. Call me when Rodgers owns his conference, and is more likely to be in the conference championship game than not - again, not by Vegas odds, over the course of his career.
And by all means, call me when Rodgers is chasing "one for the thumb" (or, as in Brady's case, "one for the other hand.")
To all the foobaw guys on the radio out there making their bones by impersonating idiots in a bar even while sober, that's a special skill, but maybe you shouldn't fixate on the foobaw part of it. You're clearly missing the goal of the game. Hell even Herm Edwards understood that part.
Rodgers is very good. He might even be among the top QBs I'd like to choose on a given Sunday to have a good shot.
Nowhere near having Tom freakin Brady back there.
One day Tom will retire, I've accepted that. They're not repaving that road any time soon, and the game will probably be flag football by then.
It's ovah. GOAT.