I think the debate could have more power with one more concussion, but I couldn't see any reason at the moment to really feel strongly that he'd be able to go right now--but then suddenly not in September. One more good lick and we may be having this discussion, however.
Off topic--I saw this on ESPN stats/twitter and thought you may like to have it passed on, with your questioning of Amendola's worth + opinion of Edelman's dominance this season. It would appear that Amendola has been much more important than many are giving credit for :
@ESPNStatsInfo
Brady: 63.6 comp pct, 8 TD, 2 Int targeting slot receivers since Amendola's return from inj (Wk 8); 58.7 comp pct, 1 TD, 4 Int in 1st 7 gms