- Joined
- Oct 10, 2006
- Messages
- 76,878
- Reaction score
- 66,861
I hear you. Unfortunately, there are so many contextual pressure points (4th quarter, 2 minutes, down by x, down by y/z, facing a top x defense, etc...), it's a practical impossibility to come up with a comprehensive stat that will both work and be acceptable.For QBs, that's why looking at win totals and playoff success should be looked at hand in hand with stats to determine how good a QB is. Brees had passing yard stat padding in playing from behind a lot. Manning had a lot of TD stat padding with many goal line throws instead of runs.
The kind of game Belichick and the Patriots played with Brady, clean and controlled games, do not lend itself to much shootouts and worthless stat padding.
The abomination that is QBR is an example of how such attempts fail.











