Best Point Comparing Brady vs. Rodgers I’ve Heard

[Ice_Ice_Brady]

Brady is Montana. Rodgers is Young


More Steve Young.

Spot on.

 

[Kontradiction]

Who you want to sleep with isn’t the argument.

Cooked him.

 

[Clonamery]

lol.....what a sh*thead reply

Hey, there’s nothing to be ashamed about. Your preference is completely subjective and in no way says anything about who you really are as a fan.

 

[TBR]

if the opportunity arose this morning, I would dump Brady in a heartbeat if I could get Rodgers

This is your most egregious post, including the political ones.

 

[lancerman]

so coaching has nothing to do with it? Mccarthy = BB?
Edgar Bennett = Mcdaniels?

LOL

We weren’t talking about coaches. Play style wise, Rodgers is more comparable to Young and he’s had similar post season results.

Also I wasn’t even comparing Rodgers to Brady so I don’t know why you would compare their coaches.

 

[IllegalContact]

Hey, there’s nothing to be ashamed about. Your preference is completely subjective and in no way says anything about who you really are as a fan.

stick to the topic you idiot

 

[IllegalContact]

We weren’t talking about coaches. Play style wise, Rodgers is more comparable to Young and he’s had similar post season results.

Also I wasn’t even comparing Rodgers to Brady so I don’t know why you would compare their coaches.

Brady is nothing like Montana so it ends right there........your entire point is wasted motion

 

[Clonamery]

stick to the topic you idiot

I quite clearly did. You prefer QBs from the legs up rather than from the head down. No shame in that. It’s what a lot of t-boys, I mean fanboys like.

 

[lancerman]

Brady is nothing like Montana so it ends right there........your entire point is wasted motion

Two most successful QB’s of the modern era, both known for clutch play. For each of their respective eras they were largely the two players that most closely resemble each other.

You’re digging into the weeds to be argumentative

 

[libra957]

That awkward time when a 41 years old will still the best qb in the league.

 

[IllegalContact]

I quite clearly did. You prefer QBs from the legs up rather than from the head down. No shame in that. It’s what a lot of t-boys, I mean fanboys like.

no you didn't.....you're just being a jackass

 

[IllegalContact]

Two most successful QB’s of the modern era, both known for clutch play. For each of their respective eras they were largely the two players that most closely resemble each other.

You’re digging into the weeds to be argumentative

they are completely different QB's ..... there is no resemblance in their play......but thanks for confirming that you are actually clueless when it comes to playing the game

 

[lancerman]

they are completely different QB's ..... there is no resemblance in their play......but thanks for confirming that you are actually clueless when it comes to playing the game

I’m didn’t claim they were identical duplicates genius, but act more like a ****. I was talking about accomplishments, reputation, perception.

But thanks for confirming you have no perception of context

 

[CISGS]

This reminds me of LeBron vs. MJ.

LeBron - More gifted physically, better athlete
MJ - More clutch, better attitude, unlimited drive, better

Brady like LeBron however, is defining age better than anyone else.

 

[IllegalContact]

I’m didn’t claim they were identical duplicates genius, but act more like a ****. I was talking about accomplishments, reputation, perception.

But thanks for confirming you have no perception of context

lol........by your logic Earl Campbell is just like Barry Sanders because they both ran with the ball and both their careers ended early......

in that case, your point is completely pointless

 

[lancerman]

lol........by your logic Earl Campbell is just like Barry Sanders because they both ran with the ball and both their careers ended early......

in that case, your point is completely pointless

Both won the most Super Bowls of their era, both known for clutch play and being the ultimate winners. Again you’re being argumentative for the sake of it and being a **** this whole thread, not just with me. Having a rough day?

 

[chasa]

the only thing that needs to be said is people don't compare brady to other qb's. People compare other QB's to brady.

Brady is the gold standard.

 

[IllegalContact]

Both won the most Super Bowls of their era, both known for clutch play and being the ultimate winners. Again you’re being argumentative for the sake of it and being a **** this whole thread, not just with me. Having a rough day?

not at all........so the pats are just like the jets because they both fill their stadiums

your comparison is meaningless

 

[lancerman]

not at all........so the pats are just like the jets because they both fill their stadiums

your comparison is meaningless

Omg you are truly obtuse. I’m making a comparison about attributes that are unique and apply to very few people (in this case there’s only a handful of QB’s in the last 40 or so years that won the most Championships in their era and were known for being extremely clutch performers). That’s very different than taking an attribute that is common to nearly the entire league to prove some silly childish point.

You’re argument is devoid of logic and baseless because you want to continue fighting a point that you truly were to dense to understand. It shows a lack of ability to reason and make comparisons and connections. I never once said Brady and Montana has similar play style. I said they are regarded similarly for what they did and how they were perceived in their era. Brady and Montana were the most successful QB’s of their time with a clutch gene. Rodgers and Young were the two most physically gifted QB’s of their time who had a great ability to run and pass that while they won a single Super Bowl, they didn’t live up to expectations.

 

[brdmaverick]

In Aaron Rodger's wildest dreams he STILL doesn't finish his career with as many rings as Brady.