- Joined
- Jul 30, 2015
- Messages
- 3,303
- Reaction score
- 8,646
Fair enough, not bad at all although I'd disagree. I feel like Brady is still the better player at this stage. Peyton walked into a dream situation & fell off a cliff right after. He already missed an entire year. Brady was in a nightmare situation this year & isn't close to as fragile as Manning was at the time.
Give him those weapons & he'll perform the #'s will be very comparable.
Props for the good post & response.
Yeah, it's all hypothetical.
If you give 43-year-old Brady a team of D. Thomas, E. Decker, J. Thomas at their absolute peaks, and a decent Welker although on the decline, and an O-line that allows about 1 sack per game, and you want to say Brady gets 5500 yards and 55 TDs or whatever it was, to me that's a slight reach. But I'm not going to argue strongly against it.
That year by Peyton pissed me off since it was Brady's TD record that he broke, although passing stats have also inflated since then in general.