Oh I agree, and I am not one of the people here who question so many of his picks as a knee jerk reaction.
I am an amateur here, unlike our resident “experts”.
Duron Harmon was a head scratcher at the time, but turned out to be a great pick.
My issue with Richards is that it looked bad at the time, and the skepticism proved to be warranted.
What did BB see in him and was there no pushback?
We don’t need “yes” men here.
There will always be reach picks. Mapu is one. Tyquan is another. Coaches fall in love with players and they get intel that other teams like them. So, for instance, Tyquan's college receiver's coach was (and maybe currently is) the Steelers' WR coach. So the Patriots jump and grab a guy they really like because they think he's going 2 picks later (even if most teams have him taken a round or two later).
This is just something that always happens.
It happened with McCourty, Mankins, even Thuney was thought to be a later rounder.
It obviously happened with Dugger too.
But remember, we've also taken guys that have "fallen" to us who were projected much higher. For instance, Malcolm Brown and Josh Uche. Sometimes there's a reason why those guys fall and it's not smart to just follow the consensus of what everybody else thinks.
Wilfork was also obviously a guy who fell to us, and so did Gonzalez. It's all a mystery really. Why some of these guys pan out and others don't.
When Belichick trades up into the 2nd round, it usually is someone he feels very strongly about (Gronkowski, Barmore). If he's trading back, he doesn't see value.