My position is Brady shouldn't have taken off smack dab in the middle of training camp to attend a family vacation. It's not an unpopular opinion. They can go on to win the Super Bowl... I'll still hold the same opinion about his absence during training camp.
My question to you was in response to this:
I don't think the time off effects Brady much but it's probably a detriment to some of the new players getting acclimated to the offense.
I asked you about which players would be detrimentally affected. I did that for a specific reason, which is that the offense has few new faces who'll need to be up to speed immediately, and those that are likely to be called upon early are veterans (some of whom were out with injury anyway) who should be able to get ready faster.
The only young "addition" is likely to be Goedeke at left guard. The new right guard is Shaq Mason, with whom Brady is certainly familiar. And, they're guards. They need to play together with the rest of the line. The QB isn't the issue there. If they were tackles, you might have more of a point.
Again, here's the situation with the team's WR1-WR4, and likely early season TE1-TE2.
Jones was out injured
Gage was/is out injured
Goodwin was/is working back from ACL surgery
Evans was out injured
Brady's been working with Brate since his arrival, leaving only
Rudolph as the guy for whom the "detriment" issue would even apply.
Finally, at RB, Brady's had plenty of time with Fournette and Vaughan, Bernard's been injured, and the only one left for the purposes of this theoretical detriment is the rookie.
You're rewording what I said (again). I never claimed anyone said it was preferable that Brady be gone. I asked how is it not preferable that Brady be there. There's a difference. Of course no one prefers Brady not be there, which only emphasizes my point that his being there would have been of some benefit. If you take away that benefit (which he did) then it's a negative. It's not complicated.
You posted the following:
how is it not preferable to have your team leader present for any chunk of time during training camp?
So, the only reason that would be an issue is if someone were to say that it's not preferable to have your leader present. And here you've acknowledged that nobody would prefer that. So, you're just building strawmen to kill, and then pouting when I don't play the game.
I suggest that you follow the first rule of holes.