The NFL world went crazy, and I'm not sure why that is.
Fantasy and Mahomes. (sounds like a seventies group...maybe opening for the Captain and Tennille or Seals & Croft?)
It's the same reason Jason Tatum drives me insane for the Cs...90% flash...sure will have a 50 point game or three, all while the opposing club is slamming home ten uncontested dunks the other way going up by double digits as another long rebound contested three facilitates the break (and he's usually complaining he got fouled at the other end).
Whatever the sport, teams win games - yes, you need superstars, but they have to be part of a team. The entirety of which have to buy into their roles (which aren't all "star" equal) and execute those roles well including the coaching which also cant be all based on individual goals, but team ones.
Numbers are great, but ultimately teams need more than just numbers. Intangibles matter. If they didn't then the fantasy winners would also win the championship every year (when usually the opposite is true and most of the fantasy leaders are in the middle of the pack or lower). Mahomes is finding out this year, without a team around him, and him shouldering too much of the load, he's overwhelmed. He can't be the QB and the CB...and the DL...and the OL...no one can.
So scouts fall in love with the shiny object they think CAN be "ALL" of it - cover up every flaw any team might have, when the reality is no one can fulfill that role. Lastly we are just as culpable - we fans clamor for the same thing...so we're given it. We want a guy that can run a 3.2 40, throw the ball 400 yards on a rope, break tackles just by looking at the defender and, oh yeah, woo the cheerleader at the end.
Ironically none of those things translate automatically to wins...but most people think that correlation is direct.