sb1
PatsFans.com Retired Jersey Club
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2013
- Messages
- 34,839
- Reaction score
- 39,214
Cassel looked horrible in preseason and he turned into a more than serviceable QB for us in 2008 when he got the call. Tebow had a pretty good game in preseason too for us. Preseason is not really a defining benchmark for a QB imo.Did you watch Stidham and JimmyG in pre-season games? Stidham was better in pre-season and that was a lot more playing time. You forgot to mention that . When you only mention the comparisons that support your argument and forget the comparisons that do not support your argument, it looks like trolling.
I have no idea if Stidham is an NFL QB or not. Neither does anyone else on PatsFans. Conjecture is Ok as long as we are measured and fair in our evaluations. You wrote, "from what I saw in KC (13 pass attempts) it appears to be a very good reason" - I do not think observing 13 pass attempts is a basis for negative or positive analysis. I do not think you knew JimmyG was the real thing after 10 pass attempts either, even though you have very positive vibes from those 10 or so passes.
Yes small sample size but Jimmy looked like he had "it". Stidham looked like the 4th round draft pick QB that he is. Like I said, Bill seems to agree that he isn't good enough otherwise he would have started over a QB with 4 passing TD and 9 INTs in 10 games already. Miami is trying to start Tua over Fitz who is playing much better than Cam - and that's because Tua is a viable NFL QB prospect. Stid isn't.