As has been pointed out, this has been pretty strange... consensus seems to be that it wasn't the slam dunk that people were hoping for due to the 6 picks we had in the first 3 rounds but it seems not too shabby either. I think we should compare with last year's draft which most will agree was a good one:
2010 1st Round (27th Overall) – Devin McCourty, CB, Rutgers -
2011 1st Round (17 overall) - Nate Solder, OL : complements Vollmer, big plus to OL. But OL still incomplete. Center remains a big problem. Guard could be leaving soon. Makes a position of strength (passing) stronger. A good addition.
2011 1st Round (28th Overall) - Traded out of for a 2012 first rounder with NO and 56th pick. Questionable trade. A player of McCourty's caliber was obtained with this pick in 2010. The 1st round pick may be higher/lower next year... time will tell. Two DL were taken in the draft immediately following but it seems DL was not considered as an area to be improved in the draft which is what has caused great grief among fans.
2010 2nd Round (42nd Overall) – Rob Gronkowski, TE, Arizona
2011 2nd Round (33 Overall) - Ras-I Dowling, CB - This pick was taken 10 positions higher than Gronkowski but there are serious issues about the durability of the player which has caused a lot of concern and understandably so. Furthermore, Gronkowski was a very solid pick so Dowling has a lot to live up to. But if this pick works out, it genuinely makes our cornerback position complete with McCourty, Bodden and Dowling. I would say it was a decent choice, only other DBs picked higher were Amukamara and Jimmy Smith. Still... Dowling better be good. This pick should count as a first round choice.
2010 2nd Round (53rd Overall) – Jermaine Cunningham, OLB, Florida -
2011 2nd Round (56 Overall) - Shane Vereen, RB - Required to maintain RB by committee approach (it is to be debated if that is the best approach) Taylor, Faulk, and Morris are seemingly done. One hopes he is as much a player as Cunningham.
2010 2nd Round (62nd Overall) – Brandon Spikes, LB, Florida
2011 2nd Round (60 Overall) - Traded to the texans for 73rd overall - No pick. Brandon Spikes wins this slot.
3rd Round (90th Overall) – Taylor Price, WR, Ohio
3rd Round (73 Overall) - Stevan Ridley RB. Adds one more RB to the group. Could make the position complete... time will tell.
3rd Round (74 Overall) - Ryan Mallet QB. Clearly a great value if one were in dire need of a quarterback but does not help the team in any way in the foreseeable future; unless Hoyer is to be jettisoned immediately.
4th Round (113th Overall) – Aaron Hernandez, TE, Florida
5th Round (150th Overall) – Zoltan Mesko, P, Michigan
6th Round (205th Overall) – Ted Larsen, C, NC State
7th Round (208th Overall) – Thomas Welch, OT, Vanderbilt
7th Round (247th Overall) – Brandon Deaderick, DL, Alabama
7th Round (248th Overall) – Kade Weston, DL, Georgia
7th Round (250th OVerall) – Zac Robinson, QB, Oklahoma State
Of the later rounds, Hernandez and Mesko were huge and we will have to wait and see if this draft can match up to that. For the most part, the draft is not terrible compared to last year's unless Solder doesn't pan out. Dowling will be KEY because that has question marks. The main problem is in the 2nd and 3rd rounds where we used picks at similar or higher positions than last year and yet did not pick up players that anybody considers very good or very useful to the team. Of course there will be more picks in the later rounds but there is good reason to be underwhelmed.
Also the trends for this team are a little worrysome. In any sport it takes individual champions to make a champion team because when the time comes, you still have to beat the other guy mano-a-mano because you can bet that if you got to the final, the opponents will be good at every spot. We have been losing our champions at rapid rate - Vrabel, Bruschi, Harrison, Seymour, Moss, and now potentially Mankins and Light and only have a few left now - Wilfork, Brady,... take your pick. Some youngsters such as McCourty, and the tight ends are showing promise but it seems we are not adding match-winning talent at the rate we are losing it and that is certainly bothersome when despite stockpiling draft picks, we don't draft a sure-fire contributor. Of course the draft is a lottery but the odds of the higher picks working out are better than the odds of the lower ones working out - they are ranked higher for a reason.
We should be looking to sign some very solid veterans to the team to stay dominant.