OT: Watson to Brownies

[Deus Irae]

This Is a team who has had garbage at QB for like 30 years. So Watson seems like an elite top tier QB in their eyes.

The reality is he's not better than Mahomes or Allen.

The more I think of it, the more I think Cleveland is screwed.

Sorry but Watson isn't worth that. No way.

This isn't Mahomes or Allen.

Rank the QBs. You don't get far before it's time to name Watson.

 

[Guts]

Rank the QBs. You don't get far before it's time to name Watson.

Bias obviously but

Brady
Mahomeboy
Rodgers
Allen
Burrow
Watson??

 

[PatsFan2]

Of course he's better.

But Watson has had injury concerns. And the dude seems like a huge headache.

Cleveland isn't even the favorite in that division imo.

The more I think on it, the more I believe Cleveland was desperate. And Watson took them to the cleaners.

They have some really good skill position players they have the pieces Watson is young wow barley in his prime.

 

[Guts]

 

[NFL Mystique]

Rank the QBs. You don't get far before it's time to name Watson.

Keep in mind he was suspended last year. So Herbert is ahead for now. Watson will miss games this year too.

Brady
Mahomes
Allen
Rodgers
Herbert
Burrow

 

[Deus Irae]

Bias obviously but

Brady
Mahomeboy
Rodgers
Allen
Burrow
Watson??

I start with the obvious 4, though I'm not sure if I'd put Allen as a first tier guy, or just the best of the 2nd tier guys right now:


Allen
Brady
Mahomes
Rodgers


Then I'd be looking at tier two QBs, with some guesswork (Watson missed the whole season, after all), and probably slotting Watson in at either 7 or 8:

Wilson
Burrow
Herbert/Watson

 

[NFL Mystique]

Bias obviously but

Brady
Mahomeboy
Rodgers
Allen
Burrow
Watson??

I think Herbert has to be above him.

Watson missed all of last year.

If this poll were done a year ago, I'd put Watson ahead.

 

[Patnation21]

Keep in mind he was suspended last year. So Herbert is ahead for now. Watson will miss games this year too.

Brady
Mahomes
Allen
Rodgers
Herbert
Burrow

Watson is better then Herbert and Burrow. He's really good. I think people forget how good he is. He's not going to forget how to play. He is looking at a suspension for sure.

 

[Ras-IR Dowling]

Browns to Baker: We will accommodate your request.

 

[NFL Mystique]

How in the world did Houston not get a roster player from Cleveland?

 

[cupofjoe1962]

The Browns are Crazy, but this will be interesting

 

[Deus Irae]

Keep in mind he was suspended last year. So Herbert is ahead for now.

If you can't remember Watson's game and you're being hazy with your choice as a result, say so. I did. But you don't automatically drop him below another player because he missed some games. That's folly.

Watson will miss games this year too.

That's irrelevant to his ranking, though.

 

[NFL Mystique]

Watson is better then Herbert and Burrow. He's really good. I think people forget how good he is. He's not going to forget how to play. He is looking at a suspension for sure.

I forget because he's been gone so long. It's just I have no recent memory of a Watson play.

I do know there are four guys who are ahead without any argument whatsoever:

Brady
Mahomes
Allen
Rodgers

There's zero case for Watson over any right now imo.

So all in all, yeah Watson is close to top five.

It seems odd they let Landry go. Cooper isn't a legit #1 receiver imo. They need a #1 & #2 receiver. Because the other AFC receivers are better.

Ugh.

 

[Ras-IR Dowling]

 

[Disco Volante]

The rest of the AFC is nervously trying to keep up pace with us adding Joe Judge and re-signing Matthew Slater.

 

[Sciz]

It's hilarious to me that Watson's agent was clearly leaking about wanting to play for his hometown Falcons in order to get more guaranteed money from the Browns.

 

[NFL Mystique]

If you can't remember Watson's game and you're being hazy with your choice as a result, say so. I did. But you don't automatically drop him below another player because he missed some games. That's folly.




That's irrelevant to his ranking, though.

Alright.

He's definitely behind Mahomes, Brady, Allen, and Rodgers. That's the top tier.

He's neck and neck with Burrow & Herbert imo.

Guys like Jackson, Carr, and Wilson are in that next tier.

 

[gobesmug]

So if Mayfield wasn't included in that trade, the Browns might be able to recoup some of those picks back

 

[Patnation21]

I forget because he's been gone so long. It's just I have no recent memory of a Watson play.

I do know there are four guys who are ahead without any argument whatsoever:

Brady
Mahomes
Allen
Rodgers

There's zero case for Watson over any right now imo.

So all in all, yeah Watson is close to top five.

It seems odd they let Landry go. Cooper isn't a legit #1 receiver imo. They need a #1 & #2 receiver. Because the other AFC receivers are better.

Ugh.

I can agree with that. I have him at 5. They're definately a little weak at WR and now have lost their number 1 draft pick. They do have two really good RB's though, maybe they package one in a trade for a WR.

 

[NFL Mystique]

It's hilarious to me that Watson's agent was clearly leaking about wanting to play for his hometown Falcons in order to get more guaranteed money from the Browns.

I think it's ridiculous what he did to NO & Atl.