Manning is more skilled than Brady? Please explain.

[Joker]

It's right here: Google

2000 - 121.4 QB rating...his team lost.

2004 - 143.8 QB rating...his team lost

2007 - 118.5 QB rating...his team lost.

2008 - 90.4 QB rating...his team lost.

The Colt's went to the post-season 8 times under Manning. This is the way HALF of them ended...again, HALF. One time, he won the Super Bowl. 3 seasons ended on a bad note for Manning. Three out of eight.

Just horrifyingly moronic,wrong,uninformed and totally ridiculous. Just WHY are you here again?

 

[Joker]

Here is four years of playoff defeats by the Colts right here:

Manning had 121.4 QB rating...his team lost. Manning has a 143.8 QB rating...his team lost. Manning had a 118.5 QB rating...his team lost. Manning had a 90.4 QB rating his...his team lost.

Are you going to say that it's Manning's fault that his team lost?

You had three brain cells...YOU LOST...TWO OF THEM.

Try "NFL STATS-Planet Earth" next time...the space shuttle back to Planet Moron is waiting for you.

 

[Joker]

I didn't create the argument. The argument was there before me. The argument IS the thread. If you disagree with what I say, that only means that you have a different opinion, not that I've lost the argument...and I don't whine about it.

And, let's be real: if I have an opinion, I obviously don't think I'm wrong. C'mon now.



I'm getting in the way of what? Everyone agreeing on something? When has THAT ever happened? I'm adding my honest opinion here while being attacked on all sides because it's an unpopular opinion to have here.

Dumb as a bag of beach sand and a sack of rocks.Tell me, Barfalo Bob, they got any left handed screw drivers up there?

 

[ausbacker]

Try searching Peyton Manning Tom Brady on youtube and you'll find some pearler commentary like "Superbowl rings are overrated anyway".

 

[Deus Irae]

Just horrifyingly moronic,wrong,uninformed and totally ridiculous. Just WHY are you here again?

You had three brain cells...YOU LOST...TWO OF THEM.

Try "NFL STATS-Planet Earth" next time...the space shuttle back to Planet Moron is waiting for you.

Ummm......

LOL, you are right, and I look stupid.

Here is the real losses:

2000: 82 QB rating
2004: 64.3 QB rating
2007: 97.7 QB rating
2008: 90.4 QB rating - this one I got right!

Not that bad, really, either though.

Here are the other ones:

1999: 62.3
2002: 31.2
2003: 35.5
2004: 69.3
2005: 90.9
2006: Super Bowl win

I gotta admit that there are some completely horrible games, here, especially the games where he was in the 30s. I also have to tuck my tail between my legs and admit that Brady has been superior in the post-season as far as consistency goes. Manning has had better games by far than Brady in the playoffs, but Brady seems to be the more stable influence, which is better. Although, Brady has won playoff games with a worse passer rating than Manning had in a loss.

I still feel that Manning is asked to do more for his team.

Sort of emphasizes the irony of this, though:

You are such a contentious d!ck that it's practically indescribable....

Have yourself a lovely evening, Mr. Blackpot.

 

[Joker]

Still smarting from a couple of days ago, eh Deus?

Keep up the obsession though...and YES, I SAW THAT POST OF HIS, you contentious freak. That DOES NOT excuse his PREVIOUS ERRONEOUS POSTS to which I added my own two cents...if that's OK with you, Mr. Jerk-of-the-century. And even if it's NOT OK with you.

 

[feldspar]

Ummm......



Sort of emphasizes the irony of this, though:



Have yourself a lovely evening, Mr. Blackpot.

I changed my mind.

I liked you better when you have me on ignore. LOL

 

[Deus Irae]

Still smarting from a couple of days ago, eh Deus?

Keep up the obsession though...and YES, I SAW THAT POST OF HIS, you contentious freak. That DOES NOT excuse his PREVIOUS ERRONEOUS POSTS to which I added my own two cents...if that's OK with you, Mr. Jerk-of-the-century. And even if it's NOT OK with you.

Not at all. I was simply pointing out the hypocrisy. You have yourself a great evening.

 

[Joker]

Hard to ignore the little short bus refugee when he's running all over a thread hallucinating.

 

[Joker]

what kind of a world would it be if there was no Deus Irae "pointing out hypocrisy" day after anal retentive day?

 

[feldspar]

Hard to ignore the little short bus refugee when he's running all over a thread hallucinating.

Keep it up, Joker. I made a mistake and admitted it.

 

[ScottieC]

Dumb as a bag of beach sand and a sack of rocks.Tell me, Barfalo Bob, they got any left handed screw drivers up there?

Joker - Lets let this one go, he admitted his mistake.

No need to repeatedly bash the guy in consecutive posts.

 

[jays52]

When I hear someone say "I would rather have Petyon Manning than Tom Brady" I instantly go from intelligent, educated football mode to "this person isn't worth the knowledge" mode. I cannot control this, it is just a natural impulse.

 

[ScottieC]

what kind of a world would it be if there was no Deus Irae "pointing out hypocrisy" day after anal retentive day?

A slightly less entertaining and insightful patsfans world. IMHO.

 

[ScottieC]

Hard to ignore the little short bus refugee when he's running all over a thread hallucinating.

That's true - But give the guy credit for staying, arguing his point and then admitting that his math failed him.

 

[feldspar]

Joker - Lets let this one go, he admitted his mistake.

No need to repeatedly bash the guy in consecutive posts.

Thanks again. I don't think he can resist using the term "Barfalo" whenever he can. And who can blame him? That's good stuff.

 

[Joker]

well, I don't feel THAT particular need....I'm not here much during the offseason...but I caught his opening act a few weeks ago and from the looks of it, he's blossomed into the prodigious troll he seemed to be then. To wit, he "sees" things differently than we do ...about Brady for instance...well, just what the hell has he been "seeing" all these years besides watching Brady humiliate his team year after year? I submit that it has gotten so mind wrackingly intolerable that he googled up this site and has decided to show us N.E.'ers "what fer!!!". Just ANOTHER in a long line of Bart Muleys. After the opening day loss, he won't be seen or heard from again. As usual.

Heh...Feldspar..an abrasive derivative of igneous rock..."Feldspar is one of several abrasive ingredients in Bon Ami, a brand of household cleaner in the USA."

"I've had enough fellow Bills fans!!! I'll go to their board and aggravate them as much as they've aggravated us all these years!!!! Those stupid Bostoners will never get my nickname, Feldspar...tee hee hee!

Poor eggy face...

 

[ScottieC]

well, I don't feel THAT particular need....I'm not here much during the offseason...but I caught his opening act a few weeks ago and from the looks of it, he's blossomed into the prodigious troll he seemed to be then. To wit, he "sees" things differently than we do ...about Brady for instance...well, just what the hell has he been "seeing" all these years besides watching Brady humiliate his team year after year? I submit that it has gotten so mind wrackingly intolerable that he googled up this site and has decided to show us N.E.'ers "what fer!!!". Just ANOTHER in a long line of Bart Muleys. After the opening day loss, he won't be seen or heard from again. As usual.

Heh...Feldspar..an abrasive derivative of igneous rock..."Feldspar is one of several abrasive ingredients in Bon Ami, a brand of household cleaner in the USA."

"I've had enough fellow Bills fans!!! I'll go to their board and aggravate them as much as they've aggravated us all these years!!!! Those stupid Bostoners will never get my nickname, Feldspar...tee hee hee!

Poor eggy face...

Living thru the 70's, 80's and early 90's - I feel the pain of losing. To that end, Jealousy and Hate is a strong motivator in the world of Pro Sports and their fans and one that you should never forget feeling, it makes these Brady/Belichick years oh so much sweeter.

We are lucky, Joker. The Brady argument is one that we should relish right now and let me tell ya, I do.

 

[feldspar]

well, I don't feel THAT particular need....I'm not here much during the offseason...but I caught his opening act a few weeks ago and from the looks of it, he's blossomed into the prodigious troll he seemed to be then. To wit, he "sees" things differently than we do ...about Brady for instance...well, just what the hell has he been "seeing" all these years besides watching Brady humiliate his team year after year? I submit that it has gotten so mind wrackingly intolerable that he googled up this site and has decided to show us N.E.'ers "what fer!!!". Just ANOTHER in a long line of Bart Muleys. After the opening day loss, he won't be seen or heard from again. As usual.

Heh...Feldspar..an abrasive derivative of igneous rock..."Feldspar is one of several abrasive ingredients in Bon Ami, a brand of household cleaner in the USA."

"I've had enough fellow Bills fans!!! I'll go to their board and aggravate them as much as they've aggravated us all these years!!!! Those stupid Bostoners will never get my nickname, Feldspar...tee hee hee!

Poor eggy face...

Uh-huh. What you are playing out is the picture of a poor winner. I'd have to be a pretty pathetic individual to come here and knock the Patriots on the basis of being a Bills fan. I'm not a troll. Period.

And no, if the Patriots murder the Bills on opening day, I'd be more than willing to discuss the way things went down. If the Bills beat the Patriots, would you be willing to do the same?

You want to label me because I'm a fan of a different team in the division? I don't give ****.

We're all just people, dude...spectators of the sport. My girlfriend is from New England. Some of my friends are from New England. Get past that. We aren't drawing a line in the dirt here, at leas I'm not. Congratulations on being from the area that has the most successful football team, if that's the case. Quite a personal accomplishment, isn't it?

Do you want to fight?

 

[ausbacker]

It's about time the personal attacks finished guys. This isn't a politics board you know...

Back to the topic at hand or let this one die out?