As someone who plays fantasy football and currently has him on my dynasty team, Davis is not that guy. He had that big playoff game against the Chiefs a year and a half ago that everyone remembers but much of that was from blown coverage. I’ll share a link that has a breakdown to why Davis is overrated as an NFL starting receiver:
Patrick Daugherty breaks down the 2023 Bills from every angle, including the passing game, running game and win total.
www.nbcsports.com
“Which brings us back to 2023. Gabe Davis is still the No. 2, but we now know it is a role for which he is miscast. Although Davis’s Week 1 ankle injury cast a long shadow over his 2022 production, it’s not a sufficient explanation for him commanding fewer than 100 targets in 15 games. Next Gen Stats charted supposed deep threat Davis as averaging only 2.8 yards of separation, placing him in the bottom third of the league and behind names like Nico Collins and Trent Sherfield . He was spotted an average of just 5.4 yards of cushion, a screaming lack of respect from opposing corners. His 1.43 yards per route run placed 56th amongst wideouts. Davis barely even contributed big plays. His 11 receptions of 20-plus yards were tied for 30th.”
Davis has success on vertical routes but not much elsewhere. Also to his credit has a nose for the end zone. But he’s not a complete wideout and definitely wouldn’t take over a game if something were to happen to Diggs. He’s strong as a role player, a WR3 type, but not a reliable go-to option. The Bills invested a first round pick on Dalton Kincaid, while already having a TE in Dawson Knox who they have signed through 2026, because they needed a stronger complimentary receiving threat to Diggs.