I don't know why people still compare Rodgers to Brady.
The more interesting discussion would be Rodgers vs. Manning.
I think Brady to Manning is a great comparison. It isn't about the accomplishments so much as their styles of play. They were a lot more similar than they were different. That's why it was such a great rivalry because both of them absolutely owned the pocket and could manipulate defenses so well. Outside of their accomplishments and accolades, I don't see Rodgers and Manning as similar.