- Joined
- Feb 4, 2018
- Messages
- 15,753
- Reaction score
- 20,088
Ben Watson? Not even close.TE Ben Watson
We all love Jules, but it’s not happening.WR Julian Edelman
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Ben Watson? Not even close.TE Ben Watson
We all love Jules, but it’s not happening.WR Julian Edelman
He'll be on a list at some point. So will McCourty.Ben Watson? Not even close.
We all love Jules, but it’s not happening.
Gunner would be the answer to the wish for an Edelman.I'm dream of a Julian Edelman (7th rounder) for Nixon... (less QB more WR)
The thing is, some of them were good picks at the time. In particular Ras-I Dowling definitely had the talent to justify that selection. It's just bad luck that he couldn't stay healthy in the pros. And you can't predict something like Cyrus Jones becoming a complete basket case, either.I feel that the first 2 rounds should be successful more often than not. That is why is our rage with 2nd round db busts are justified. 3rd and 4th round have lower expectations and so forth. This draft has been better than you can ask for. We are getting rookie of the year performances out of Mac, Barmore, and Stevenson. The rest are a work in progress and I have a good feeling about Perkins.
It's freaking stupid.How many times do we need to go down the road of poor drafts in this winning franchise??. every draft has winners and losers as their ability to adapt to the NFL cannot be gauged by viewing tape, talking to their coaches and the combine.
How can we gauge how well Perkins, McGrone, Bledsoe, Sherman or Nixon will play as most have not played a down in the NFL yet?? The jury hasn't even been convened on these 5 players..
How many times do we need to go down the road of poor drafts in this winning franchise??. every draft has winners and losers as their ability to adapt to the NFL cannot be gauged by viewing tape, talking to their coaches and the combine.
How can we gauge how well Perkins, McGrone, Bledsoe, Sherman or Nixon will play as most have not played a down in the NFL yet?? The jury hasn't even been convened on these 5 players..
Group-sourced insight sometimes works. The draft forum usually comes to a good consensus. I think we'd do a credible job. Three contributors per year is my guess.Oh, no. Patsfans lawyers, marketing gurus, HVAC installers, computer nerds, sanitation specialists and finance pros would definitely draft better than BB. Don’t you know that yet? Please keep up.
Read my post again. These two will be on the list. I didn't say they are HOFers. They will be one of the approx. 14 players added each year to voting.Ben Watson? Not even close.
We all love Jules, but it’s not happening.
I definitely think McCourty deserves to be on the HOF voting list but he just hasn't had the accolades he deserves.He'll be on a list at some point. So will McCourty.
I know what you meant and didn’t misread it. Edelman never made a Pro Bowl or All Pro. He’s only had 1,000 yards 3 times and had 36 total TD’s. Wouldn’t shock me if the voters to get on the list see through his postseason performance as he had many opportunities. It’s hard for him to get consideration when he wasn’t even among the best of his generation.Read my post again. These two will be on the list. I didn't say they are HOFers. They will be one of the approx. 14 players added each year to voting.
Ben Watson is 13th all time in receptions for TEs, top 20 in TDs and Yards. You better believe he will be on the ballot. Anyway you cut it, when you draft a guy who is top 15, top 20, in the 3 most important categories, it's a great pick.
It's freaking stupid.
Bill misses on draft picks. Same as the other 31 teams.
Historically they've always picked in the the bottom 1/3rd which makes the odds even longer to draft an impact player
"That said, I absolutely won't criticize anyone who hated the picks of Tavon Wilson and Jordan Richards, who were both drafted several rounds too early. I also have issues with the trade up for Duke Dawson, which made little sense at the time."The thing is, some of them were good picks at the time. In particular Ras-I Dowling definitely had the talent to justify that selection. It's just bad luck that he couldn't stay healthy in the pros. And you can't predict something like Cyrus Jones becoming a complete basket case, either.
That said, I absolutely won't criticize anyone who hated the picks of Tavon Wilson and Jordan Richards, who were both drafted several rounds too early. I also have issues with the trade up for Duke Dawson, which made little sense at the time.
Ras IR Dowling was a pretty controversial pick at the time due to how many bad injuries he had suffered prior to the draft. Ditto with Dominque Easily. These are one of my most hated picks.In particular Ras-I Dowling definitely had the talent to justify that selection. It's just bad luck that he couldn't stay healthy in the pros. And you can't predict something like Cyrus Jones becoming a complete basket case, either.
That's true, and I'll own up to being upset about all of the above being picked. They were all very similar situations in how they were generally evaluated pre-draft and how early they were drafted in the end. However, just because the approach worked 1 of 4 times doesn't make the criticism of the 3 misses completely invalid. The insight should come from examining what was different about Harmon."That said, I absolutely won't criticize anyone who hated the picks of Tavon Wilson and Jordan Richards, who were both drafted several rounds too early. I also have issues with the trade up for Duke Dawson, which made little sense at the time."
The same thing was said about Duron Harmon.
There are times when 9 out of ten ham and egger draftnicks would have made a better player selection than BB. (See N'Keal Harry, Jordan Richards, Tavon Wilson, Justin Rhorwasser, Lawrence Maroney, etc. ) I'm not hating on BB, but there have been many times where a lesser informed casual fan would have picked a much better player.Oh, no. Patsfans lawyers, marketing gurus, HVAC installers, computer nerds, sanitation specialists and finance pros would definitely draft better than BB. Don’t you know that yet? Please keep up.
There are times when 9 out of ten ham and egger draftnicks would have made a better player selection than BB. (See N'Keal Harry, Jordan Richards, Tavon Wilson, Justin Rhorwasser, Lawrence Maroney, etc. ) I'm not hating on BB, but there have been many times where a lesser informed casual fan would have picked a much better player.
Harry was one of those dreaded "draft risers". I heard chatter the night before the draft that Harry was sneaking up boards. Those guys always worry me. While he was projected to be a 1st rounder, I saw most rated him as the 4th or 5th WR to come off of the board. Richards, Wilson and the K were idiotic picks. Maroney was not a "WTF" pick as he was right up there as the 2nd best RB after Bush. Williams and MJD had their red flags and there was a reason they dropped.There are times when 9 out of ten ham and egger draftnicks would have made a better player selection than BB. (See N'Keal Harry, Jordan Richards, Tavon Wilson, Justin Rhorwasser, Lawrence Maroney, etc. ) I'm not hating on BB, but there have been many times where a lesser informed casual fan would have picked a much better player.
In 2010 BB traded up to draft a TE with major injury concerns and skipped over a favorite of many of the "experts" here, Sergio Kindle.There are times when 9 out of ten ham and egger draftnicks would have made a better player selection than BB. (See N'Keal Harry, Jordan Richards, Tavon Wilson, Justin Rhorwasser, Lawrence Maroney, etc. ) I'm not hating on BB, but there have been many times where a lesser informed casual fan would have picked a much better player.