The funny thing is the Pats probably can legitimately push back with Gonzalez on the Witherspoon deal to some extent.
Witherspoon received the top 5th year option worth 21m. Gonzalez received the 2nd highest 5th year option worth 18m. The reason, although they have both been 2nd team allpros, Witherspoon has been selected to the probowl all 3 seasons, Gonzalez has only been selected once. Witherspoon was also selected as a top 10 pick, ahead of Gonzalez in the 2023 draft, and Witherspoon has already regularly been a team captain with the Hawks.
I'm not saying Witherspoon is a better player or Gonzalez isn't worth a bigger contract. I'm saying the Patriots can (and probably are) legitimately asking why do you deserve significantly more than him during negotiations, especially if Gonzalez's team is genuinely asking for a deal that completely resets the market.