PATRIOTS NEWS Edelnuts in Pats HoF

[maust]

Gratz to Jules, well deserved...

Knew the vote was going to go his way, based on the poll here... the final tally here was
Edelman 54.5%
Vinatieri 42.9%
Mankins 2.6%

That vote was rigged. RLKAG would have won in a landslide

 

[The Gr8est]

Let's not leave out his huge catches vs Sea or that he was SBMVP in 53.

How about the catch where he is blasted by Kam Chancellor, hangs onto the ball, and still has the presence of mind to get up and keep running.

His knee had touched the ground, but still.

 

[The Gr8est]

These moments come to my mind very frequently and every bit as iconic.

Damn!

Brady steps up in the pocket like a boss!

 

[The Brandon Five]

Gratz to Jules, well deserved...

Knew the vote was going to go his way, based on the poll here... the final tally here was
Edelman 54.5%
Vinatieri 42.9%
Mankins 2.6%

Thread 'Patriots Hall of Fame Finalists - Edelman, Mankins & Vinatieri (Vinatieri vs Edelman)'

Apr 10, 2025

The fan vote has begun...

** Cast Your Vote Here ** --> 2025 Patriots Hall of Fame Ballot


The Three Finalists are WR Julian Edelman, G Logan Mankins & K Adam Vinatieri

Simple Question is: Who ya got...
Slightly Harder Question: Why...

Please, Opine, if you care to share...

and yeah, I left RLKAG off on purpose.

from the Pats website...

Patriots Announce 2025 Hall of Fame Finalists

"The New England Patriots revealed two new names among this year's nominations for hall of fame consideration, as recently eligible candidates...

• Pape
• Replies: 322
• Forum: PatsFans.com - Patriots Fan Forum

Mankins? Mr. October?

 

[The Gr8est]

Well-deserved.

I hope the next step is Canton. He might not have the regular season numbers, but his playoff numbers are second to... Rice and that's it, I think.

When you think of HOF players you think of players who rose to the occasion and made a difference.

First five years be damned, in the playoffs and SB Edelman rose to the occasion and was as big a difference maker as anyone ever was.

 

[JMC00]

The people complaining because of Viniateri not getting in aren't ready to have the discussion that Ghost was a better kicker for us than Viniateri. Ghost just doesn't have that GW playoff kick but kind of not his fault since he was the kicker when Brady climbed to the top of G.O.A.T mountain, whereas Viniateri was kicking for us with when Brady was just starting up the mountain.

 

[mike_usagisan]

Good job squirrel! Is AV guaranteed next year?

 

[Steve102]

When you think of HOF players you think of players who rose to the occasion and made a difference.

First five years be damned, in the playoffs and SB Edelman rose to the occasion and was as big a difference maker as anyone ever was.

He doesn't have the pro-bowls, all-pro teams, and regular season stats that voters love. The snobs will look at him as a product of Brady's greatness and discount or disregard him. A shame really.

 

[upstater1]

I was in the camp about Vinitieri getting in first, but that was before I realized that he and Edelman retired at the same time. For some reason I blocked out that he spent even more time with the Colts than he did with the Patriots and retired in 2020.

Vinatieri had some of the most iconic moments in Patriots history (two kicks in the Snow Bowl and two last second Super Bowl victories) compared to Edelman's one in the Atlanta Super Bowl, but I think a receiver is more important component to a team than a kicker. There is a reason there are 29 WRs and only 4 kickers in the NFL HOF.

Also 2014 Super Bowl (where he was walloped hard and continued on w/ a concussion) and the MVP in the 2018 SB. His numbers in the Super Bowls are spectacular, averaging over 100 yds and 10+ catches.

If there were a Playoff HOF or Super Bowl HOF, then Edelman would be a shoe-in.

 

[The Gr8est]

He doesn't have the pro-bowls, all-pro teams, and regular season stats that voters love. The snobs will look at him as a product of Brady's greatness and discount or disregard him. A shame really.

Yet guys like Jerome Bettis are in the HOF.

Guy played small against the Pats.

Gained one yard and got up and danced.

WTF is up with spellcheck?

My typos would be more readable than spellcheck changes it to.

Spelling “Bettis” took about five tries.

 

[upstater1]

These moments come to my mind very frequently and every bit as iconic.

3rd and 14 down 10 in the 4th qtr. and you just get walloped and suffer a certain concussion, but yet you get up and run for a big gain. This play was arguably the biggest play in a Super Bowl victory.

I'll remind everyone that though Adam's kick was huge at the end of the Carolina game, he missed two short FGs earlier in the game.

 

[Pape]

That vote was rigged. RLKAG would have won in a landslide

thats why i left the ****er off

 

[The Gr8est]

3rd and 14 down 10 in the 4th qtr. and you just get walloped and suffer a certain concussion, but yet you get up and run for a big gain. This play was arguably the biggest play in a Super Bowl victory.

I'll remind everyone that though Adam's kick was huge at the end of the Carolina game, he missed two short FGs earlier in the game.

Gotta feel for Kam Chancellor on that play.

What more was he supposed to do?

 

[JMC00]

and two last second Super Bowl victories

I kind of don't give him credit for FG against the Panthers. He missed a 31 and 36 yard FG in a dome in that one. Was the reason why they even needed to kick a GW FG.

 

[PatsFan2]

Well deserved.

 

[JMC00]

Good job squirrel! Is AV guaranteed next year?

Nope. Gronk is eligible and he's 100% getting 1st ballot'd

 

[RobertWeathers]

Well-deserved.

I hope the next step is Canton. He might not have the regular season numbers, but his playoff numbers are second to... Rice and that's it, I think.

Kelce is ahead of him now

 

[PatsFan2]

Remember the time BB let him test the FA market?? I bet the Giants were kicking themselves for not signing him then. So glad he came back in the fold. Just amazing how he emerged into a very good WR...not many converted QB's make that switch effectively.

 

[maust]

thats why i left the ****er off

In other words, you rigged the vote by omitting an obvious winning candidate from the poll.
You really are a great American, bless you in your continued efforts to save us from ourselves. You're doing the Lord's work!

 

[Joey007]

There’s very few more deservi by than Edelman for this honor. Guy put himself out in harms way for us over and over again when we needed him the most.