Amazing stat/fact regarding Aaron Rodgers

[Soliel]

Aaron Rodgers has never had a 4th qtr comeback against a team with a winning record.

"But, but he can make all the throws"!

Sorry if this has been posted prior, but I just heard this on radio and could not believe it. And some people actually think he is better then Brady. By this fact alone I think he is barely a top 10 QB all time.

All Rodgers is about is luck. He got lucky once. He’s a good quarterback athletic wise but he has no ability to rise to the occasion and win consistently

 

[TB_Helmet]

Your Brady outside # is wrong. It should be 96.9

Thanks, I was staring at that thinking about how some of my usual Brady GOAT evidence was suddenly in question.

 

[TB_Helmet]

All Rodgers is about is luck. He got lucky once. He’s a good quarterback athletic wise but he has no ability to rise to the occasion and win consistently

Not to go all in defending Rodgers, but I think it's important to be objective lest we lose credibility. He's one of the top 5 QBs of the past 20 years, maybe as high as 2, and he should and will be in the Hall of Fame. It's fine to acknowledge that while at the same time understanding that he's not as good as Brady. And his lack of 4th quarter comebacks notwithstanding, he's lost a lot of playoff games where his defense gave up 30+.

 

[aluminum seats]

I wouldn't throw her out of bed , but I'll agree she's overrated. Lots of models have prettier faces and the skinny fashion supermodel body type has never really done it for me.

Pretty much agree, but I will say I sort of loved her when she went CRAZY during the Super Bowl comeback against Atlanta.

 

[BradytoMosstoGronk]

For some dumb reason I had first take on this morning (I don’t watch those two morons, please don’t burn me), and the lengths Kellerman and Stephen A will go to defend Rodgers is astounding. You couldn’t toss out a negative (Rodgers) metric they wouldn’t vehemently oppose. Woody actually took a realistic stance and said he deserved blame and Kellerman about popped a blood vessel.

Rodgers is great, athletic, once in a generation talent. What he isn’t? A guy who you want leading you down 2 touchdown in the fourth. His body language never gives me the impression he’s got that killer instinct, or the will to win. He’s a front runner, and that’s it.

Great stat guy, athletic as you’ll ever find, but not a true legend on Brady’s level.

 

[Soliel]

Not to go all in defending Rodgers, but I think it's important to be objective lest we lose credibility. He's one of the top 5 QBs of the past 20 years, maybe as high as 2, and he should and will be in the Hall of Fame. It's fine to acknowledge that while at the same time understanding that he's not as good as Brady. And his lack of 4th quarter comebacks notwithstanding, he's lost a lot of playoff games where his defense gave up 30+.

I know and I don’t really disagree for the most part. I just always hate double standards. Brady is eviscerated every time he loses. The same bozos don’t care if Rodgers loses seven straight.

 

[Anteros]

I would like to see proof of the validity of that stat. I find that hard to believe.

This is the original article from nearly two years ago, complete with the 35 games.

2016 NFL Conference Championship Predictions

 

[Wheelman]

.

 

[TB_Helmet]

This is the original article from nearly two years ago, complete with the 35 games.

2016 NFL Conference Championship Predictions

Thanks for posting that. Liked this quote:

With Green Bay, you’re talking about a team that’s 9-18 on the road against teams with a winning record since 2011.

Given that the Packers are a 'Public' team for gambling purposes (and also for ownership purposes as their fans will obnoxiously remind you), Vegas gives them extra points because they know people will take them. This stat is incentive to go in the opposite direction.

 

[Deus Irae]

Not to go all in defending Rodgers, but I think it's important to be objective lest we lose credibility. He's one of the top 5 QBs of the past 20 years, maybe as high as 2, and he should and will be in the Hall of Fame. It's fine to acknowledge that while at the same time understanding that he's not as good as Brady. And his lack of 4th quarter comebacks notwithstanding, he's lost a lot of playoff games where his defense gave up 30+.

I use Manning's rookie year as the cutoff. I think that, while there's a chance for some of the more recent draftees to impact the list, the top 11 seem pretty clear, with the top 2 being obvious, and the rest being more fungible.

Brady
P. Manning

The order of the next 3 is arguable, imo, though I think most people would slot Roethlisberger as the least of the 3:

Rodgers
Brees
Roethlisberger

The rest are in no particular order:

McNabb
Rivers
Ryan
Newton
Wilson
Luck

And, in case anyone is wondering, I did not forget about Eli, Flacco or Palmer (might have made it if he hadn't had that knee injury that changed his career).

 

[TB_Helmet]

I use Manning's rookie year as the cutoff. I think that, while there's a chance for some of the more recent draftees to impact the list, the top 11 seem pretty clear, with the top 2 being obvious, and the rest being more fungible.

Brady
P. Manning

The order of the next 3 is arguable, imo, though I think most people would slot Roethlisberger as the least of the 3:

Rodgers
Brees
Roethlisberger

The rest are in no particular order:

McNabb
Rivers
Ryan
Newton
Wilson
Luck

And, in case anyone is wondering, I did not forget about Eli, Flacco or Palmer (might have made it if he hadn't had that knee injury that changed his career).

I think Rodgers vs Peyton at #2 is a debate. Rodgers may lose because he had to sit for the first three years of his career, so Peyton gets a big start out of the gate. But if you adjust for that, it's pretty close. I'd be interested to hear other people's opinions given that it's not a topic that's discussed that much, given that everyone's just compared to Brady.

 

[Coolade2]

Stat means he's a mental midget... Or he's crippled by the system he plays under.. and he knows it. These comparisons are really inconclusive since you have so many variables.

Kinda pointless but still interesting stat.

 

[Danger Zone]

would be interesting to see AR in NE with the coaches we have in place...

I love winning, but after Brady, having a passive-aggressive eye-rolling diva would drive me crazy.

 

[supafly]

I think Rodgers vs Peyton at #2 is a debate. Rodgers may lose because he had to sit for the first three years of his career, so Peyton gets a big start out of the gate. But if you adjust for that, it's pretty close. I'd be interested to hear other people's opinions given that it's not a topic that's discussed that much, given that everyone's just compared to Brady.

Manning has gone to the SB 3x, won with two different teams, and has a lot of stats in his favor.

Rodgers may be a better athletically gifted pure passer than anyone of his era in the sense that Marino was, but he’s got to prove himself with 4th quarter comebacks, win some playoff games, and go to some SBs before I’d put him above Manning, and arguably even Brees for that matter.

 

[everlong]

Your Brady outside # is wrong. It should be 96.9

Thanks, typo.

 

[DarrylS]

Heard the same stuff on Sportstalk and it was generated by a national pundit, and repeated by Bertram I believe.. apparently there is some info out there that validates what was said.. not sure if it true or not, but if you repeat a lie often enough it somehow becomes true.

The tweet is generated by Scott Kacsmar in a Jan 21, 2017 tweet..

Aaron Rodgers: 0-35 when trailing by more than 1 point in 4th quarter against teams with a winning record

Wait, are we really arguing that Aaron Rodgers isn't clutch?

Aaron Rodgers is now 0-37 when trailing by more than one point in the 4th quarter to a team with a winning record. That’s a real stat. #GBvsMIN #SNF #Packers #Vikings

— Will Presti (@WillPresti) November 26, 2018

 

[Joker]

I told all of you he was the jumpy punk discount double dork narcissist he's always been...way back when Brady was being eviscerated by that damnable scumbag Turdell. "Erring" closed his yap like a giant clam at the Great Barrier reef and let his so-called "good friend" Brady twist in the fiery wind of that repugnant witch hunt. **** him and the jackazz he rode in on. I hate that egomaniacal azzole with a vengeance. He rides on this magic carpet of broken play jumping throws that make ESPN highlights like it's a friggin religious experience. Have you ever wondered WHY he's always breaking out of the pocket and throwing across his body all the time? It's because he's AVERAGE when it comes to reading defenses and always has been.
Can't stand this arrogant POS and find it constantly aggravating that THIS fanbase puts so much energy into lusting for HIM over the greatest QB to ever play the game.

 

[Sparetire]

Quarterbacks don't win by themselves, coaching/GMing in GB is pathetic. Aaron has more talent and is better than TB, but he's not the GOAT.

 

[RobertWeathers]

Quarterbacks don't win by themselves, coaching/GMing in GB is pathetic. Aaron has more talent and is better than TB, but he's not the GOAT.[/QUOTE

So your position is AR would have had more success in NE than Tom?

 

[captain stone]

I use Manning's rookie year as the cutoff. I think that, while there's a chance for some of the more recent draftees to impact the list, the top 11 seem pretty clear, with the top 2 being obvious, and the rest being more fungible.

Brady
P. Manning

The order of the next 3 is arguable, imo, though I think most people would slot Roethlisberger as the least of the 3:

Rodgers
Brees
Roethlisberger

Brees > the Fivehead.