Deshaun Watson Media Love-Fest

[meatface]

He's a career 58 percent completion guy who had ONE great season and five mediocre ones.

Saying his first four seasons were mediocre is just not true. He isnt Tom Brady but that doesnt make him garbage

 

[meatface]

That's not what I was responding to. I response was why no one likes him.

With regards to your question, kinda easy.

Top10

Brady
Rogers
Ryan
Wilson
Roeth
Brees
Cousins
Rivers
Stafford
Flacco
Luck
Carr

You can take two out and add Prescott, Mariota and Eli and get serious consideration as better game managers and better passers than Newton.

Joe Flacco in the top 10, for shame. You also cant competently ignore Newtons running, but to each his own.

 

[tom444]

That's not what I was responding to. I response was why no one likes him.

With regards to your question, kinda easy.

Top10

Brady
Rogers
Ryan
Wilson
Roeth
Brees
Cousins
Rivers
Stafford
Flacco
Luck
Carr

You can take two out and add Prescott, Mariota and Eli and get serious consideration as better game managers and better passers than Newton.

I have a lot of respect for Ryan as an individual. I followed, and liked him at BC. He appears to be a solid, mature, leader, that I would respond to. But 31 unanswered points down the stretch in a SB, I can't rate him at #3. I'd like to, but he wasn't able to rally the troops when he had to.

 

[RobertWeathers]

Joe Flacco in the top 10, for shame. You also cant competently ignore Newtons running, but to each his own.

Take out Flacco and Newton is still not in the top 10.

His MVP season seems more like a fluke

 

[RobertWeathers]

I have a lot of respect for Ryan as an individual. I followed, and liked him at BC. He appears to be a solid, mature, leader, that I would respond to. But 31 unanswered points down the stretch in a SB, I can't rate him at #3. I'd like to, but he wasn't able to rally the troops when he had to.

Yea I got lazy with the ordering after TB and Rogers. 3rd, 5th, 8th , doesn't matter.

Big Matty Ice fan too. Some credit does go to NE for completely shutting down ATL.

 

[SalemPats]

No im not joking. the NFC west was by far the worst

Seattle is far and away better than anyone in the AFC South and i would take the Cards over the Texans

 

[BobDigital]

Said it before and will say it again. Bust. He can't throw accurately. Only 2 QBs from this class likely have a chance to be good and they were the first 2 taken this year. Maybe 1 will work out and maybe the other will be able to stick around.

 

[rochrist]

Saying his first four seasons were mediocre is just not true. He isnt Tom Brady but that doesnt make him garbage

If you can't break 60 percent completion, yeah, you're pretty much mediocre.

 

[meatface]

If you can't break 60 percent completion, yeah, you're pretty much mediocre.

Just curious what are guys who just scrape 60%? Is this the mendoza line or is it the difference between being a scrub and great for you?

 

[rochrist]

Just curious what are guys who just scrape 60%? Is this the mendoza line or is it the difference between being a scrub and great for you?

Closer to the former than the later. Certainly breaking 60 doesn't make you great. But falling below it is pretty bad in today's pass happy league that's all but outlawed pass defense.

 

[IcyPatriot]

Watson has a noodle arm ... not good.