It's not whether Wolf HAS been fired, but whether he OUGHT to be. The captain's language may be ... robust, but he is right.
Wolf's draft was terrible.
Oh, people say, that's because he hasn't had the time to implement his system.
But his free agency was terrible too. Not just pre-season free agency but during the season too -- compulsively swapping out one JAG lineman for another. How are you going to get the minimal amount of cohesion -- not killing drives with pre-snap penalties -- if you keep chopping and changing?
Oh, people say, you can't judge his players because of the terrible coaching they got.
But where did the terrible coaches come from? That NFL powerhouse the Browns gave you AVP and Peters and so on. And who brought them in? Eliot Wolf.
The only reason to keep Wolf is that it would be disruptive to remove him before the draft.
After that, Wolf must go!
Here's the overall issue. This is the first year you could judge Wolf with full control and didn't have Bill Belichick around ignoring scouts and just doing whatever he wanted and it was a mixed bag but their are mitigating factors.
-He did get Drake Maye, people can call it a no brainer pick but we have reason to believe the regime last year wouldn't get him.
-He got Milton who looks like he's one of the best back ups in the league and might get us value later on.
-He ****ed up on passing on McConkey for Polk. That was a miss. I also don't think anyone reasonably expected that to turn out as bad as it did. This board was practically drooling over Polk after the pick and through all the training camp reports and Brissett was getting crucified for not throwing to him early in the season. So it was a big miss, but some people are being facetious in pretending there weren't reasons to think it might end up being the right move. Also this is by far the biggest negative against him.
-The rest of the draft besides the two QB's didn't pan out much either, but Wallace got placed on IR after a month so we don't know for sure what he's going to shape up as. He was generally considered to be playing good before that. If he comes back and plays strong on the line, we are going to look at that draft very differently.
Now we get to free agency.
-Let's just start at the beginning that we all know needs to be addressed. This was supposed to be a really strong free agency period and became the weakest in recent memory specifically because there was a very unexpected cap increase and players who were going to hit the market were able to work out deals to stay on their teams. Pretending this didn't have a significant impact is foolish. It made a huge difference in what we could do and it came off like we had two or three players we valued and because they were the only people there, we were dragged in a bidding war.
-Aiyuk and Ridley were the big gets we were after and we didn't get them. On one end you could say "well that's on Wolf for not selling the team". Truth is there wasn't much to sell. Maye had no track record, we were coming off a ****ty run, we had a new coach with no pedigree. Aiyuk imo clearly just wanted a deal with the 49'ers and was leveraging everyone else. Ridley just didn't want to be here and has played in the South his whole career and went to another Southern team.
-Flipside is you could argue we should have focused elsewhere. But let's be real, everyone saying we should have gone for the lineman, all the supposed tackles in free agency ended up being guards. This was a very strong RB free agency. But did you want to lock a ton of money into that position? Idk.
So yes there was a mixed results. The successes were top loaded at QB, there is a mystery in Wallace, and then we sucked at free agency when there were a lot of reasons it should have sucked.
After 6 years of being under Bill's thumb do you say this is Wolf's only bite at the apple with all the things that went against us this year, especially after he got the QB? I think that's a bad idea overall. You do need to give him a fairshake to see what he can on average produce. Since the alternative is to give a coach who never had roster control the responsibility and go to an archaic "the cook buys the groceries" model that the rest of the league doesn't use anymore.... the smart move is to see what Wolf does this year and next year, if it doesn't work out you go on a GM search.