What is Joe Milton worth?

[Toofy]

Teams needing QB


Colts
Steelers
Giants
Browns
Titans


Available decent free agent QB still - Rodgers , Daniel Jones, Cousins ( if released or traded)

QBs in draft class - cam ward, sanders maybe

2nd rounders uncannily bust every odd 2 year.

Drafting a QB beyond top 10 is like roll of dice . No gurantees.

If sanders better than Milton - probably not .

Is this a great draft class - No ?

Can you play the season without a QB - no.

Should I spend a 2nd or 3rd or even 15th on sanders --- really don't want to.

Is trading Milton for a 2nd rounder on a okay draft class with no great QBs after 1 that high a risk - absolutely not.

Upside of Milton panning out - you could become like eagles who got Jalen hurts for a second round.

We should probably trade Milton to only the team that gives us their first round pick for our 3rd and 4th. QB is a premium . Someone will bite the bullet. Else trade Milton for a starter LT.

 

[TommyD4207]

If we assume Milton is better than any QB in this draft, why would the Pats trade him for a day 3 pick?

I don't know that he's better than Cam Ward, although it's a pretty narrow gap. That would be the only one.

 

[Brotherblues]

Milton + 2nd (38) + a 4th

for

Pitt 1st (21) + Pitt 6th

We take Simmons or Golden at 21 and TeSlaa or Hollin Pierce with the 6th.

 

[TommyD4207]

Milton + 2nd (38) + a 4th

for

Pitt 1st (21) + Pitt 6th

We take Simmons or Golden at 21 and TeSlaa or Holin Pierce with the 6th.

Can you imagine if we make a trade with Pittsburgh and it doesn't involve George Pickens? There will be a 10-deep line at the Tobin.

That would be an incredible trade if they pulled that off, btw.

 

[The Gr8est]

Milton + 2nd (38) + a 4th

for

Pitt 1st (21) + Pitt 6th

We take Simmons or Golden at 21 and TeSlaa or Hollin Pierce with the 6th.

I don’t like sending picks back, certainly not a high 4th.

There will be competition for a rare commodity.

If a team doesn’t like the price than keep your picks and go with what you have, or trade up for Sanders.

We are fine keeping Milton.

 

[TommyD4207]

I don’t like sending picks back, certainly not a high 4th.

There will be competition for a rare commodity.

If a team doesn’t like the price than keep your picks and go with what you have, or trade up for Sanders.

We are fine keeping Milton.

If you're getting 21, you have to do it 10 times out of 10.

 

[tuckeverlasting]

if, on draft day, one of carter or hunter are still available at 3, do you call the giants and offer milton and 4 for 3 which is the equivalent of pick 50 ? now he's in the nfc.

 

[Toofy]

Milton + 2nd (38) + a 4th

for

Pitt 1st (21) + Pitt 6th

We take Simmons or Golden at 21 and TeSlaa or Hollin Pierce with the 6th.

Slight change

Milton + 3rd ( our high 3rd) + 4th - Pittsburgh 21.

I don't want to give our 2nd . If we do we value Milton at 3rd rounder . Milton is worth somewhere between pick 35-40 and if there are multiple teams an overpay might be needed.

 

[UGAPatsfan]

Can you imagine if we make a trade with Pittsburgh and it doesn't involve George Pickens? There will be a 10-deep line at the Tobin.

That would be an incredible trade if they pulled that off, btw.

I’m tellin ya…Pats should want NO PART of Pickens. Headcase going all the way back to UGA.

Just…an idiot

 

[TommyD4207]

I’m tellin ya…Pats should want NO PART of Pickens. Headcase going all the way back to UGA.

Just…an idiot

Yes, I agree.

 

[Sorrynotsorry]

If we trade milton... i hope it's a direct trade not for some crazy craps shoot draft...

It better be a bad ass player...

If we would have had a real coach last year... and milton would have been put in more games... instead of the" veteran"qb...

1. We might have won more games
2. I feel the starting job would be something to be earned.

It's still not impossible to have 2 really good qbs with maye as the starter and milton as the relief.

I think milton is superior athletic compared to maye... i think maye has a higher foot ball iq.



Wanna see him run?

 

[DarrylS]

He is worth more to us than anybody else...
We need a strong back up quarterback... he fits that bill.

 

[The Gr8est]

Just heard Tom Curran suggest Joe Milton for Jacobi Meyers, straight up.

That is a “No” from me.

 

[Ross12]

If you're getting 21, you have to do it 10 times out of 10.

21 is a golden location. If you take Travis Hunter at #4, you can likely get a solid tackle at #21. If you take Will Campbell or a different tackle at #4, you can likely get a solid WR at #21.

 

[Love The Drake]

Just heard Tom Curran suggest Joe Milton for Jacobi Meyers, straight up.

That is a “No” from me.

100 percent no,

 

[mgteich]

Teams needing QB


Colts
Steelers
Giants
Browns
Titans

Is this the list of teams seeking an NFL QB with one day of pre-season level experience?

 

[The Gr8est]

Is this the list of teams seeking an NFL QB with one day of pre-season level experience?

Teams seeking an improvement in their QB prospects, yes.

 

[Bill Lee]

Teams needing QB


Colts
Steelers
Giants
Browns
Titans


Available decent free agent QB still - Rodgers , Daniel Jones, Cousins ( if released or traded)

QBs in draft class - cam ward, sanders maybe

2nd rounders uncannily bust every odd 2 year.

Drafting a QB beyond top 10 is like roll of dice . No gurantees.

If sanders better than Milton - probably not .

Is this a great draft class - No ?

Can you play the season without a QB - no.

Should I spend a 2nd or 3rd or even 15th on sanders --- really don't want to.

Is trading Milton for a 2nd rounder on a okay draft class with no great QBs after 1 that high a risk - absolutely not.

Upside of Milton panning out - you could become like eagles who got Jalen hurts for a second round.

We should probably trade Milton to only the team that gives us their first round pick for our 3rd and 4th. QB is a premium . Someone will bite the bullet. Else trade Milton for a starter LT.

Seems Jones went to Indy at around 11 AM...

2025 NFL free agency live updates: Tracking signings and trades, latest news on Aaron Rodgers, other QBs

Keep it locked here for the latest offseason buzz as free agency continues into the second week

www.cbssports.com

Not sure if this takes Indy out of the game since GM Ballard is saying they want competition, but my guess is that paying a 1st for Milton and getting back our 3rd+4th is too rich for them.

If I were a rival GM, I'd take us signing Dobbs as a sign that we just aren't that into Milton and are using him as trade bait. Definitely seems like a decent posture to take entering negotiations.

 

[rkarp1]

please excuse me while I laugh at these trade proposals

 

[Pape]

Can you imagine if we make a trade with Pittsburgh and it doesn't involve George Pickens? There will be a 10-deep line at the Tobin.

That would be an incredible trade if they pulled that off, btw.

If milton is the real deal, theres no effing way i am trading him to Pitt (or nyj, nyg, den. balt, mia, etc) ... not setting those bastards up for future success unless the trade scenario screams "do it"... multi firsts etc...

if milton is a flash in the pan (my opinion) then eh, push for pickens, but take their second and run...