By my scale he gets an incomplete for 2022, after receiving a C+ as a rookie... which is a very good score for a rookie QB.
despite the really bad situation which should be considered by looking at the valuation of the overall performance,
we need to look at mac jones and just mac
like how did he move in the pocket, how was his awareness for delayed blitzes etc, how were his mechanics, his velocity, decision making etc.
i know this is influenced by the ****show this offense has been
but there are factors which were ONLY caused by mac's poor performance on some throws
patricia or the o-line is not the reason mac can not thrów more than 7-8 yards to his right side on outside throws, the reason for this were his mechanics
and no, mac did not forget his pocket awareness just because of patricia or showed no improvements in mechanics just due patricia
he worked with tom house in the offseason a lot and he showed no improvement on things he can improve or showed in his rookie year
do you think just because of patricia that mac did not improve his awareness for example?
Mac has to take some blame too for his development
Every offensive player gets a mulligan from last season, they couldn't overcome the incompetence of the offensive coaches.