Shaun John 9294
Rookie
- Joined
- May 20, 2010
- Messages
- 39
- Reaction score
- 0
This is a funny thread lol. Sure most of these moves have risks but as Mike Tannenbaum said, they are all calculated, low cost risks. We didn't go all Dan Synder style in the offseason. I'll review what we did this past offseason.
Santonio Holmes - We only traded a 5th rd pick to acquire him, which I'm sure you guys wouldn't of mind throwing up a 4th rd pick instead of starting ancient Torry Holt while Welker recovers. he is suspended for the firs 4 games, but that won't hurt us too much. Braylon Edwards isn't going to be suspended and only fined from what I've read so no biggie there. He is also on a 1 year deal. Worst case scenario he sucks and we move on. This trade was an easy one.
Antoinio Cromartie - He was a monster in 2007. No coincidence that was the last year Shawn Merriman was relevent. Their pass rush hasn't been the same since and they changed their scheme from press man to man(similar to what Ryan runs) to a lot more zone coverage(which Cro clearly fails at). Anyone who can pick off Peyton Manning 3 times in one half has great ability. With the Jets he will be back in a press man to man scheme along with a team that applies as much pressure as possible, which allows our defense to cover opposing players as little as possible. Along with trying to populate Cali over the years, he had 7 kids that defintely led to distractions. He is human how can it not? We gave up a 3rd that may, and hopefully, turns into a 2nd based on playing incentive. I say hopefully because that means hes beasting it for us. He is also on a 1 year deal. Worse case scenario he sucks/gets injured, Kyle Wilson steps in the following year and we move on.
LaDainian Tomlinson - He is tougher to project. We released Thomas Jones because he was SHOT by the end of the year and practically loss his starting spot to Shonn Greene, who is his replacement not Tomlinson. Tomlinson will be filling in Greenes role from last year. San Diegos oline has declined mightly these past few years along with losing Lorenzo Neal, one of the best blocking FBs of all time. They completely changed their philosophy, and rightfully so, due to the combination of progress in Rivers and the decline in LT and the run blocking. Tomlinson isn't the same from his 2006 MVP season that much is clear but we do not need him to come in and put up 32 TDs. We just need him to be a change of pace back, provide good plays on 3rd downs, and bring excellent pass protection out of the backfield, and occasionally red zone TDs. All 4 of those aspects he can still do well. He will be getting a tremendous upgrade on the oline and at FB with Tony Richardson. Again for his role he should be fine but he is a injury risk. He signed a 2 year/$5M+ deal so if he is terrible, can easily be cut in the offseason.
Jason Taylor - Similar to LT but not as important to the team. We have our starter in Bryan Thomas, we just need a better pass rusher on obvious passing downs. Some may say he can't do that but hes gotta be better then Thomas in that category. Strictly 3rd down pass rusher. He signed basically a 1 year deal due to big bonus in year 2, so again minimum risk. Might as well say 1 year deal.
Brodney Pool - Kerry Rhodes' replacement, will be an upgrade in athletism, physical play, and playmaking ability. Rhodes has better coverage skills and awareness but is coming off one of the worse seasons of his career. Pools issue isn't that he can't play but that he can't stay healthy. Am I expecting big things from him? No but he can't play any worse than how Rhodes played last year. This is more of a addition by subtraction move. Rhodes wasn't gonna play good here regardless so how good he could be is irrelevent for us.
Cutting Alan Faneca - Absolutely the biggest question mark of our off season. Huge asset in the runnning game and just as much as a liability in the passing game. Can open up huge holes while also getting our QB single-handley killed. Is the player we replace him with going to be better? No. Based on our acquistions can we afford to take a slight step back? Absolutely. You can't improve everywhere one very move just isn't realistic. This is more for the future and us getting much younger across the oline.Hopefully his replacements step up. At least they will be inbetween 2 pro bowl caliber players in Mangold and Brick to ease the transition.
Our Draft - Kyle Wilson was a coin toss away from being the #7 overall pick so I obviously love the pick. He is also insurance for Cromartie and will help us where we got hurt the most in the playoffs, depth in the secondary. Ducasse is an awesome athlete with tons of potential. Whether he plays LG this year or not, atleast he gives us much needed depth with his ability to play multiple positions. Joe McKnight is a underachiever who could easily turn it up or become nothing. He was a 4th rd pick so very small investment on our part though he can become good. Leon having a double compound fracture all but assures hes not going to come back the same. I wish him the best but we got younger and more athletic at RB. The FB Conner was a luxury pick with Tony Richardson possibly playing is final season, we have someone who can step in immediately while learning from one of the best to ever do it the following year.
I don't think we had a bad offseason at all, especially considering we were limited by the final 4 rules. I feel like plenty of teams wish they added the amount of talent that we did and it could of been a lot worse(Bills?). John Clayton thinks we had the 3rd best offseason in the NFL. I think we had the best but thats my opinion. The AFC East reloaded on a lot of new talents, this year should be another war zone.
Santonio Holmes - We only traded a 5th rd pick to acquire him, which I'm sure you guys wouldn't of mind throwing up a 4th rd pick instead of starting ancient Torry Holt while Welker recovers. he is suspended for the firs 4 games, but that won't hurt us too much. Braylon Edwards isn't going to be suspended and only fined from what I've read so no biggie there. He is also on a 1 year deal. Worst case scenario he sucks and we move on. This trade was an easy one.
Antoinio Cromartie - He was a monster in 2007. No coincidence that was the last year Shawn Merriman was relevent. Their pass rush hasn't been the same since and they changed their scheme from press man to man(similar to what Ryan runs) to a lot more zone coverage(which Cro clearly fails at). Anyone who can pick off Peyton Manning 3 times in one half has great ability. With the Jets he will be back in a press man to man scheme along with a team that applies as much pressure as possible, which allows our defense to cover opposing players as little as possible. Along with trying to populate Cali over the years, he had 7 kids that defintely led to distractions. He is human how can it not? We gave up a 3rd that may, and hopefully, turns into a 2nd based on playing incentive. I say hopefully because that means hes beasting it for us. He is also on a 1 year deal. Worse case scenario he sucks/gets injured, Kyle Wilson steps in the following year and we move on.
LaDainian Tomlinson - He is tougher to project. We released Thomas Jones because he was SHOT by the end of the year and practically loss his starting spot to Shonn Greene, who is his replacement not Tomlinson. Tomlinson will be filling in Greenes role from last year. San Diegos oline has declined mightly these past few years along with losing Lorenzo Neal, one of the best blocking FBs of all time. They completely changed their philosophy, and rightfully so, due to the combination of progress in Rivers and the decline in LT and the run blocking. Tomlinson isn't the same from his 2006 MVP season that much is clear but we do not need him to come in and put up 32 TDs. We just need him to be a change of pace back, provide good plays on 3rd downs, and bring excellent pass protection out of the backfield, and occasionally red zone TDs. All 4 of those aspects he can still do well. He will be getting a tremendous upgrade on the oline and at FB with Tony Richardson. Again for his role he should be fine but he is a injury risk. He signed a 2 year/$5M+ deal so if he is terrible, can easily be cut in the offseason.
Jason Taylor - Similar to LT but not as important to the team. We have our starter in Bryan Thomas, we just need a better pass rusher on obvious passing downs. Some may say he can't do that but hes gotta be better then Thomas in that category. Strictly 3rd down pass rusher. He signed basically a 1 year deal due to big bonus in year 2, so again minimum risk. Might as well say 1 year deal.
Brodney Pool - Kerry Rhodes' replacement, will be an upgrade in athletism, physical play, and playmaking ability. Rhodes has better coverage skills and awareness but is coming off one of the worse seasons of his career. Pools issue isn't that he can't play but that he can't stay healthy. Am I expecting big things from him? No but he can't play any worse than how Rhodes played last year. This is more of a addition by subtraction move. Rhodes wasn't gonna play good here regardless so how good he could be is irrelevent for us.
Cutting Alan Faneca - Absolutely the biggest question mark of our off season. Huge asset in the runnning game and just as much as a liability in the passing game. Can open up huge holes while also getting our QB single-handley killed. Is the player we replace him with going to be better? No. Based on our acquistions can we afford to take a slight step back? Absolutely. You can't improve everywhere one very move just isn't realistic. This is more for the future and us getting much younger across the oline.Hopefully his replacements step up. At least they will be inbetween 2 pro bowl caliber players in Mangold and Brick to ease the transition.
Our Draft - Kyle Wilson was a coin toss away from being the #7 overall pick so I obviously love the pick. He is also insurance for Cromartie and will help us where we got hurt the most in the playoffs, depth in the secondary. Ducasse is an awesome athlete with tons of potential. Whether he plays LG this year or not, atleast he gives us much needed depth with his ability to play multiple positions. Joe McKnight is a underachiever who could easily turn it up or become nothing. He was a 4th rd pick so very small investment on our part though he can become good. Leon having a double compound fracture all but assures hes not going to come back the same. I wish him the best but we got younger and more athletic at RB. The FB Conner was a luxury pick with Tony Richardson possibly playing is final season, we have someone who can step in immediately while learning from one of the best to ever do it the following year.
I don't think we had a bad offseason at all, especially considering we were limited by the final 4 rules. I feel like plenty of teams wish they added the amount of talent that we did and it could of been a lot worse(Bills?). John Clayton thinks we had the 3rd best offseason in the NFL. I think we had the best but thats my opinion. The AFC East reloaded on a lot of new talents, this year should be another war zone.
Last edited:











