Pats were 8 for 16 in 3rd down conversions
Giants were 7 for 14 in 3rd down conversions
I guess the Giants will be tearing down their defense too.
Firstly, the Pats were 7/14, and the jints were 8/16.
Secondly, I expect the highest-scoring offense in 16-game (30 years) NFL history to convert about half of its 3rd downs.
Thirdly, allowing 50% on 3rd-down conversions is not championship-caliber.
Fourthly, even that high % is misleading:
One of those missed 3rd downs was converted on 4th down.
One was a 3rd/18, and another was a 3rd/16.
So, on 3rd/4th downs of 11 yards or less, the conversion rate was 9/14 for 64%.
This is why our defense needs to change, both in personnel and in scheme.
My recommendations:
1) Get smaller in the front 7.
We need a Paul Posluszny-type at WILB: young, instinctive and fast. Someone who can stay with RBs and TEs in coverage, and make tackles from sideline-to-sideline. 6'2", 240 is big enough.
We need another Jarvis Green at DE: young, strong and explosive. Someone who is OK vs. the run and can collapse the pocket. 6'4", 280 is big enough.
We need another OLB who can rush, and tackle, the QB, and who isn't a total liability in coverage. 6'3", 250 is big enough.
One or more of these players will probably have to come from the draft, maybe even in the top 100. That's right, Bill: you must draft our LBs of the future, Now.
2) Get bigger in the back 4.
We need a new Rodney Harrison at SS: big, tough, smart and fast. Someone who can blitz, tackle in the open field, cover and intercept. 6'2", 220 would be perfect. I don't feel that James Sanders is that guy, though I like him as a tweener nickel SS/FS.
We need an Antonio Cromartie-type at CB: tall, strong, and sure-handed. Someone who can play press/man-to-man coverages, esp. in close games, and isn't afraid of being left on an island. 6'1", 200 would be perfect.
3) Abandon the Bend But Not Break philosophy while the game is close. Of the jints 8 drives, half lasted 8 plays or longer. One that didn't, resulted in a TD, anyway. There were only 2 3-and-outs. Now, if we can get younger and faster at DE, WILB, OLB and SS, then we can afford to stay on the field a little longer before becoming exhausted. Still, I love seeing 3-and-outs; they are uplifting for us, and demoralizing for them.