Mack Herron
Pro Bowl Player
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2006
- Messages
- 15,110
- Reaction score
- 21,141
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.
So the NFL says Tom Brady = 3rd, Jamie Collins = 4th, and then Byrd = Van Noy (how?) and Phillips/Allen = Shelton/Karras. Apparently Roberts and Ebner just don't count... but then why does Byrd?
So the NFL says Tom Brady = 3rd, Jamie Collins = 4th, and then Byrd = Van Noy (how?) and Phillips/Allen = Shelton/Karras. Apparently Roberts and Ebner just don't count... but then why does Byrd?
Meanwhile, Allen counted while never playing a down.Playing time is a factor, but there was zero reason to believe that Byrd at $1.6M and 89% of snaps would count while Roberts at $2M and 39% of snaps or even Ebner at $2M at 4% of the defensive snaps wouldn't.
So the NFL says Tom Brady = 3rd, Jamie Collins = 4th, and then Byrd = Van Noy (how?) and Phillips/Allen = Shelton/Karras. Apparently Roberts and Ebner just don't count... but then why does Byrd?
Meanwhile, Allen counted while never playing a down.
So the NFL says Tom Brady = 3rd, Jamie Collins = 4th, and then Byrd = Van Noy (how?) and Phillips/Allen = Shelton/Karras. Apparently Roberts and Ebner just don't count... but then why does Byrd?
You missed that both had Special Teams snaps. 9.49% for Roberts and 80.5% (322) for Ebner.Playing time is a factor, but there was zero reason to believe that Byrd at $1.6M and 89% of snaps would count while Roberts at $2M and 39% of snaps or even Ebner at $2M at 4% of the defensive snaps wouldn't.
Never seen a player who spent the entire year on IR count in the Comp formula before.Meanwhile, Allen counted while never playing a down.
I don't believe that matters, or at least that Korte doesn't think it matters. He posted a snippet of his spreadsheet lately that included a column for offensive/defensive snaps, but not ST.You missed that both had Special Teams snaps. 9.49% for Roberts and 80.5% (322) for Ebner.
Playing time is a factor, but there was zero reason to believe that Byrd at $1.6M and 89% of snaps would count while Roberts at $2M and 39% of snaps or even Ebner at $2M at 4% of the defensive snaps wouldn't.
The comp pick formula is now explicitly stated in the CBA. ST gunners like Slater and Bethel get screwed, because it only rewards playing 25%+ of snaps on O or D. [There is a separate formula for kickers and punters.]I don't believe that matters, or at least that Korte doesn't think it matters. He posted a snippet of his spreadsheet lately that included a column for offensive/defensive snaps, but not ST.
The comp pick formula is now explicitly stated in the CBA. ST gunners like Slater and Bethel get screwed, because it only rewards playing 25%+ of snaps on O or D. [There is a separate formula for kickers and punters.]
Basically, Byrd's contract, based on value alone, started off just below the cutoff. Ebner and Roberts started off just above. Enough players just below the line, including Byrd, had large enough playtime percentages to push them over the line and push Ebner and Roberts under.
The basic idea is this: all players are ranked based on the annual average value of their contracts, including LTBE incentives and NLTBE incentives earned in the first year. The highest player receives a point total equal to the number of players with contracts (this year, 2164). The second highest player receives one less point (2163), the third highest player gets one less, and so on down to the lowest-paid players.You say its explicitly stated. So how exactly do contract & play % add up in this formula?