Pretty much in agreement and have been saying for years: most coordinators are neutral overall. Call 60 plays a game, win a few big ones, lose a few big ones, and 90% of the time the players/chance decide the outcome. Not a Josh fan, but he pretty much fits that mold.
Agreed but I'd say he's been a + asset overall. A little better than the norm overall in terms of calling plays. Plus in terms of the guy you want next to the QB all year round. I think he was a great sounding board, listener and overall asset for Brady. He's not going to overhaul your team or pull anything out a hat but he's a good OC imo. I would never hire him as a HC. Don't want him here as a HC but can appreciate what he's done he here for 15 years.
Unless they changed out the whole system to something much different (like McVay/LaFleur/Shanahan) they could bring in the next guy and he’d have similar results as McDaniels.
Personally I might only say McVay here. Shanahan is really good at what he does. Not sure I'd say he's really reinventing anything. I see him as his "daddy's son" in that regard and is more just an extension of Mike without the regular boys haircut and old spice cologne. Like if Mike "lived a little" but the old man was great.
Not sure Mcvay is either really but I love what he did with condensed sets in the passing game. He went against the norm there when every one else is getting spread happy he's going tight. Getting his WR's free releases while making them an extension of the run game at the end of the line. I love watching a team play together and every one on that offense is a fist most of the time so to speak. Like at times every one except the QB is a blocker. Utilizing Gurley in the passing game (obviously didn't reinvent anything but utilized his best player and didn't ignore the obvious). I think you could point to him as a very good play caller but again that's subjective and I'm sure the Rams have a DKF that thinks McVay sux.
If McDaniels is in fact dictating the team’s personnel decisions, scouting, draft, due to his own beliefs, then sure, get him out of here….trying to lowball and shy away from physical talent at WR doesn’t work without Brady, and wasn’t working anymore with him. But I doubt Josh has that power…I think it’s Bill who makes all those calls.
I tend to believe most of draft stuff is on Nick with Bill having a final say. I haven't seen or heard anything saying Josh had a big influence or really any
real influence at all in that respect. Again I'm sure he's dropping names of who he'd like and letting it be known what type of player he likes but I'm not seeing anything credible pointing to him pulling the strings.
Not so complicated to see that with the Patriots personnel this year you’re looking to take advantage of “competent skill player depth” and must switch up personnel often because without creating positional mismatches, the unit will struggle. Lots of good players; no great ones.
Yup. This is why I don't mind 10 "trick or gimmick" plays a game. People want "explosive" plays, I do too but where are the explosive playmakers?? Just like on defense, when you don't have that talent to win straight up you have to manufacture it.
Expanding on this ... I wasn't surprised by no moves bc this year is really all about assessment. What can Mac do with the current group. What they can achieve as a whole. Guys like HT, Wino, Uche, Williams, Harry. I think we tinker a good deal next year and make a decent size push around 2023 if things work out.
If you want to see a scheme that actually makes a big difference, watch the Saints. They’ve been an outlier for 4-5 years, but few paid attention because Brees was there. In reality, Brees had been very limited for a long time. They brought in Bridgewater and reeled off five wins. Brees hurt? Winston does fine. Taysom Hill gives you a chance. All injured? Ehhh..let’s just have Siemien run it. Michael Thomas injured for two years? Whatever. Offense is a masterpiece. They’ll ultimately fail because the QB talent gap catches up to everyone eventually, but what they’ve done for so long deserve tremendous praise.
Yea SP is a cut above in that respect.