Favre in 2009 was an MVP candidate and Harvin did well. From 2010-2012 I give him even more credit than you do because he put up very respectable numbers with ****ty QBs throwing to him.
He still has the jets and can break games open but he can't stay on the field with any consistency. Because of various maladies he has only played in 36 games of a possible 64 games in the last 4 seasons.
All in all, I'm willing to take a chance on the guy. He's still a game breaker when he's on the field, and playing with Brady in this offense, I believe he has a chance to be special. We're not talking about a 3-5 year deal; we're probably talking about a one year incentive-laden deal that's in the 3-5 million range. Worth the shot for a talent like that.
I have no use for Amendola. I'd cut him if it were up to me. The guy drops the ball in big spots all the time and doesn't make enough plays for my liking. He's been a big disappointment IMO. Everyone says we need him as insurance in case Edelman goes down, but he's never adequately been able to fill that role of dependable slot WR.
If we could bring in Harvin and Anquan Boldin for 3-4 million per year each, I'd be very happy with that.
Both of them are better on the outside than Amendola, and both of them have experience playing in the slot successfully if Edelman were to go down. Harvin brings you more big play ability and Boldin brings you that reliability/consistency.
Chad Jackson was a failure for a variety of reasons. And yes, the year he was cut, he was fully healthy..
I know he was healthy when he was cut in 2008.
My question is, when you suffer that many consecutive injuries in such a short period of time to your leg areas, is it too debilitating to recover from?
From 06-07, Jackson suffered hamstring, groin, and ACL injuries that may have just rendered his body a shell of its former self.
Because you'd think even if he couldn't work out in the Pats system, which is notoriously difficult for guys who can't connect mentally with Brady, a guy with his natural physical skill set could find success in another less complex offense where he can just get vertical and use his 4.3 speed to blow by DB's downfield. Kind of like a Joey Galloway, who couldn't adapt mentally to this offense but had success throughout his career in other places using his great deep speed and natural physical tools.