This thread has run it course. A story about Mac, working on his conditioning has devolved into the same old Mac Sucks, and Mac is fine diatribes that are pretty much the same story we've had on a half dozen OTHER threads.
Here's the thing: Mac Jones will BE taking the first team snaps for this team at the beginning of camp REGARDLESS of what happens over the next 5 months before camp starts. I believe that Mac STILL has to win that job. If Zappe does better in camp and outplays Mac, I believe strongly that he'll get the job.
Bill has shown over the years that his teams are a meritocracy where the best players play the most snaps. We all know that Brady outplayed Drew in the 2001 camp. Mostly because he was much better suited to run the offensive system Bill wanted. That TC Bill got a very close look at the QB's because Bill was THEIR coach. ALL the dynasty books that came out later, said the even if Drew hadn't gotten hurt, he as about 1 or 2 games away from being replaced. If Bill wasn't afraid of replacing a $100M, QB who had been to a superbowl, replacing a young QB coming off a bad year would be easy for him. So all the Mac haters, don't give up there is STILL hope. I hope to see a lot of you at camp this year. (TC is the best thing about retirement.)
In my mind I still hold out hope that Mac will come back and be the kind of QB who can lead his offense into a deep playoff run, He has the speed AND agility to be more "escapeable", yet thus far he hasn't had the experience to make that call and move. I hope this is an area he will work on this spring. (and there are drills you can use to work on that)
But where I really split with the Mac haters is their belief that getting the great QB is the ONLY way to make it to the promised land. Right now what WE need to do is to improve our roster in 3 main areas.. OL, CB, and WR Adding just ONE stud in each of those areas through the draft and FA will VASTLY transform a decent team into a contender.
Here's my Hypothetical - With our first 2 picks in the draft we go CB, WR. I think BSG will agree that there will be more value and a surer choice at #14 for a CB than at OT. Not a great year for stud OLmen after the top 2 (I believe) there will a a nice group that are pretty much interchangeable that there is s decent shot for one to be there at #46. But instead of going OL at 46, I'd prefer a WR. Again WR is going to be a deep deep position, I believe (and I can't believe I'm saying this) we are more likely to find a future #1 WR in the draft than in FA. If a good but limited Meyers is the top FA WR, then sorry that ISN'T a great WR market in FA. If a #1 WR is the goal, then we are more likely to find it in the draft than FA.
So instead of spending FA money on receivers, I'd rather spend it on DT's and OT's, Our DL had a really good year. Godcheax had a much better year, Wise had a breakout year, Guy was his usual solid self, and Ekule made strides. But adding a DRon Payne would make our DL terrifying in the ways they could come at you. Team him with Barmore on passing downs and you will need at LEAST 3 blockers to attempt do control them. Now combine them with Judon's power, and Uche's speed we SHOULD have one of the better 4 man rushers in the league.
ALSO he is only 25 with his best years ahead of him. Like most "studs" adding one makes everyone around them better
I've heard a lot of talk about someone like McGlinchey, but I REALLY like the idea of moving Trent back to RT. and adding a LT, but the LT market is very small, and only Orlando Brown at almost 27, is under 30. Unfortunately he is going to have a LOT of offers in this market, So keeping Trent at LT and improve his play will be the best play and add a RT. It's tricky.
The OTHER thing I'd like to see happen is a trade for Alvin Kamara. Kamara is simply the best 3rd down back in the league and #2 isn't close. GRANTED he comes with baggage which is likely to be a 6 game suspension. But in my mind it might be a good thing in the long run, since it will drive DOWN the cost to attain him. NO is in disarray. A mid round 4ht or 5th might look good to get Kamara's cap off their payroll. When he retired, I didn't think losing James White was going to be a problem, but with Montgomery going down 2, the lack of that James White role was laid bare. I want it back
To get this, we need to get rid of some people, Smith is the best option here. 2 years and it never worked. In some sense I'd like to see what BOB could do with Smith and Henry, but right now he is a luxury proposition. Add his, what 12MM, and that will pay dividends down the road.
So add the FLUID future #1 WR and immediate #1 CB in the draft while adding 2 very solid DT/OT in FA and we have the beginnings of a great long term run toward another title. Anything else we get this off season will be gravy
So let's drop this never ending whining about Mac and get on with adding the pieces to a more stable run to annual playoff berths