Uptown
Hall of Fame Poster
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2016
- Messages
- 24,373
- Reaction score
- 50,917
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Did I say that?Ok cut him then
He got 4 targets. Thats not open A LOT. And if he ran the wrong route he isn’t openTHE BALLS HE DROPPED.
And the one where he cut short and Maye threw long - looked like Polk's mistake, but again, OPEN.
1) Maye is a better QB today than he was a week ago, because he gained valuable experience.I would love nothing more than to be wrong about not starting Maye this year but if you think 1 game answers that question then you are delusional.
Also, even if I am wrong about that does not mean I am automatically wrong about everything else. Finally, I would love to hear why I am wrong in thinking the Texans D look their foot off the gas after going up 3 TD late in the 3rd quarter (27-7).
Very cool to see Boutte playing so well.Boutte is ahead of Polk right now on my dept chart. We need to see what Thornton and Baker can do with Maye let the auditions begin.
To some extent, I appreciate that he is pressing because it tells me that he cares and wants to win. Just needs to settle. I think he will eat some humble pie this week and hopefully start delivering more steady performances.I think he will be a good WR but he’s pressing, he needs to settle down.
Here’s another comparison last years JUJU SCHUSTER-SMITHIt’s difficult to be too hard on a guy who has been a starting WR for 6 games and compiled a total of 78 receiving yards. I don’t know that any WR ever has done that poorly regardless of the qb.
It is epically bad, perhaps worst ever, or at least since the passing game rules changed.
Here is some perspective.
2020 NKeal Harry with Cam Newton at QB in 14 games and 9 starts. 33 catches for 309 yards.
That’s 2.4 for 22.1 per game.
2024 Polk 6 games 5 starts 10 catches for 78
That’s 1.7 for 13 per game
Harry produced 41% more catches and 70% more yards.
To add salt to the wound Harry caught 57% of his targets, Polk is catching a horrifically low 43%.
He’s been given a chance in 6 games and may have posted the worse production numbers for a starting WR in the last 40 or 50 years.
Polk also had Brisket throwing to him, and dropped easy completions this past Sunday with Maye. Lets let the season play out, shall we?Here’s another comparison last years JUJU SCHUSTER-SMITH
after 6 games (despite missing game 6) had
25 targets
14 receptions
85 yards
Polk through 6 gsmes
23 targets
10 catches
78 yards.
Polk did that in 258 snaps juju played 193
Polk has been worse than Juju was and everyone in NE was calling for Jujus head.
So you are telling me that having Mac Jones and Zappe is an advantage?Polk also had Brisket throwing to him, and dropped easy completions this past Sunday with Maye. Lets let the season play out, shall we?
Why?All the WRs on this team have a clean slate right now as far as I'm concerned.
Because they might have a legit, real QB throwing to them. Funny how 2 WRs had their first ever TDs yesterday. That isn't a coincidence.Why?
So Polk slate wasn’t wiped clean when Maye started? You do realize he was worse with Maye than with Brissett right?Because they might have a legit, real QB throwing to them. Funny how 2 WRs had their first ever TDs yesterday. That isn't a coincidence.
| 271 | 12K |
| 2 | 454 |
| 15 | 1K |
| 0 | 215 |
From our archive - this week all-time:
April 8 - April 23 (Through 26yrs)











