By all means let's keep it civil. Let's go over your "list" shall we.
Frank gore - 1,600+ yards his 2nd year. No comparison to Maroney possible.
Tiki Barber - Shared the ball with Gary Brown until his breakout year. Maroney has nobody to split the ball with in 2007 except for Faulk. What's his excuse?
Travis Henry - Busted out with 1,400 yards rushing and 1,300 yards rushing his 2nd and 3rd years. Again no comparison with Maroney here.
Brian Westbrook - Best example you've found so far. Fact remains that he has always had far better hands than Maroney and was a 3rd round pick. Therefore he was not expected to produce as a starter right away like a 1st round back would. And if he wasn't doing it in the running game at least he could contribute with catches. Maroney's simply not at that level.
Tatum Bell - Terrible example. Denver's Oline makes any RB look great. He fell off the map as soon as he moved to Detroit.
Fred Taylor - Worst example you've picked so far. He busted out for 1,200 yards his rookie season and hasn't looked back since.
Ladell Betts - Who? Are you just throwing darts at a wall at this point? He's had one good year, which now looks like an aberration.
Deuce McAllister - Broke out with 1,300 yards his second year and 1,600 yards his third year. Again no comparison to Maroney.
Joseph Addai - 1,000 yards his rookie year, and on pace to get at least 1,000 more in his second year. No comparison to Maroney, this guy got on a roll his first year out. He's better than Maroney hands down.
So out of your ENTIRE list, 1 out of 9 RBs might be comparable to Maroney in terms of their careers. And Maroney doesn't have half the hands that Westbrook does. Basically you decided to throw a bunch of names out there and hope to impress me? I actually looked at their stats on football-reference.com. You know who Maroney still compares to best as of right now, Kevan Barlow.
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/BarlKe00.htm
I'm not going to hold my breath that Maroney will turn out to be a Westbrook, especially since he doesn't have the hands to hold Westbrook's jock. Thanks for playing though, come again!
2006
Frank Gore (8)
Tiki Barber (5)
Travis Henry (7)
Brian Westbrook (7)
Tatum Bell (2)
Fred Taylor (5)
Ladell Betts (4)
Deuce MacAllister (10)
Joseph Addai (7)
actually only 166 carries, but close