The arm strength talk makes me laugh. You know who has GREAT arm strength? Lamar Jackson. You know who cannot throw a touch pass to save his life? Lamar Jackson. You know who cannot find the open receiver down field and overthrows him by 2 feet? Lamar Jackson.
Yet, every pundit likes Lamar Jackson because he has all the athletic qualities. Same with Cam back in the day. Those guys are GREAT athletes and will dominate on their athletic ability alone. They are also VERY fun to watch and will sell a lot of shirts. However, when the pressure is on and they need to rely on their reads and on making the smart play, they look like ****.
I'll take a limited guy like Mac Jones who masters the mental aspects of being a QB before a super athlete with low football IQ. Of course, you'd prefer someone that has both, but that would mean you would have Patrick Mahomes or Aaron Rodgers. I'll settle for poor man's Brady/Manning/Brees. Remember the critics about Brady. "Skinny, not strong enough, cannot run". Not saying that Mac will be TB12, nobody likely will ever be, but I firmly believe he has what is needed to be successful in this league. What does "successful" means? Top 5? Top 10? I do not know, but I know he will at least be an above average starter. Will he head a new dynasty? Probably not. But I think we can win one with him.