- Joined
- Mar 21, 2011
- Messages
- 40,661
- Reaction score
- 47,163
Can any of those guys legitimately read a defense. Maybe mike Vick. The other 2... no
At least Jackson comes from a system based upon the same philosophy. That might give him a hands up.
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Can any of those guys legitimately read a defense. Maybe mike Vick. The other 2... no
At least Jackson comes from a system based upon the same philosophy. That might give him a hands up.
There's running, and then there's running. Having that ability doesn't mean you have to turn into a RB at the first opportunity. What it can do though, is add immeasurably to a QBs escapability and his ability to extend plays. Half of Rogers' success is due to his being able to extend plays with his feet causing the defense to break down.It's not a video game and this isn't an RPG character. Jackson doesn't need to allocate limited skill points to develop his running ability. If the Patriots draft Lamar Jackson, they're not going to throw out their offense and start running the wishbone and the triple option, which is what a lot of people seem to imply with the "running quarterback" thing. He'll be a pocket passer, just like he was in college; he'll play similarly to Russell Wilson.
My point to the Flutie and Gannon examples was that there's no one profile for quarterbacks who play into their 40s. There's only a handful of these guys in league history and they're widely divergent in how they played football or what they were like coming into the NFL. Plenty of mobile quarterbacks entering the league like Gannon have reinvented themselves into traditional pocket passers as they got into their 30s. Eagles Vick was much less of a runner than Falcons Vick, and Vick played 15 years in the league. McCown's an interesting example because he was a proficient runner when he first came out and had 3 or 4 attempts per game when he was a starter in Arizona. He still had 3 rushing attempts per game last season in New York and scrambled well, scoring 5 rushing TDs.
One thing I would say is that I can’t ever remember a Patriots pick being telegraphed like this Jackson one is. Maybe Harvey Langi but he was a UDFA ultimately. There was that Navy QB whose name escapes me, Su’a Cravens and Tyrann Matthieu that we’re heavily linked to the Pats pre-draft but of corse, they went elsewhere.
Rating doesn't tell you much. Brissett had a lower yards/attempt, threw for far fewer touchdowns, and took nearly twice as many sacks (one every 10 dropbacks). He also had a top-10 wide receiver in Hilton and a good tight end in Doyle to throw to, while Newton was stuck with Funchess and Byrd. McCaffrey was Newton's safety valve and his yards per attempt have sank from a league high in his MVP season as he's lost his downfield threats (Smith, LaFell, Ginn, etc.)
Newton does throw too many picks, and that hurts his QB rating. He's certainly not Brady as a passer, but that's not a fair comparison either because the number of passers who are Brady's level can be counted on one hand, maybe one finger. But it's worth noting that Cam's only 28 and Brady didn't turn into the all-world QB we know and love until his age 29-30 seasons, either. Note that Brady also had interception percentages around 3% until 2006 or so, as well, when he was a year older than Newton will be this year.
And 2017 Brady wouldn't have been 2017 Brady if he was throwing to the likes of Funchess and Byrd instead of Gronk and Cooks and Amendola, either. Supporting cast matters and, despite the insistence of Andy Johnson, the Panthers' skill position players have been wanting most of his career.
One thing I would say is that I can’t ever remember a Patriots pick being telegraphed like this Jackson one is. Maybe Harvey Langi but he was a UDFA ultimately. There was that Navy QB whose name escapes me, Su’a Cravens and Tyrann Matthieu that we’re heavily linked to the Pats pre-draft but of corse, they went elsewhere.
Keenan Reynolds out of Navy who ended up switching to Wr for the Ravens.
If the pats want him badly, they are going to have to trade ahead of Baltimore or Arizona who are looking QB as well.
Thanks, I always get stuck on that name. I still think they may have drafted him until that trade forward with Seattle happened. Although the fact we didn’t sign him after he was cut may suggest otherwise.
Yeah he was a popular pick for a slot wr conversion due to his navy ties. We do need to look at slot wr this wkend. Berrios and trey Quinn would be my two faves personally
I have a sneaky hunch for DaeSean Hamilton who could step into the Jordan Matthews role next year. Anthony Miller is another I love. If you get a chance, watch him block.
I think there's a lot of arguing from the conclusion that happens when people evaluate work ethic at the NFL level. A few people can coast on talent but not very many, most of the athletes at the NFL are working their asses off all the time.
There's a tendency to ascribe success to hard work, which has a strong basis in fact, but then to also argue the reverse and assume that lack of success was due to lack of hard work, when that's far from the case. A guy like Josh McCown works his tail off to be average because that's the most his talent can do for him. Matt Cassell by all accounts was a workaholic and managed to leverage not much talent into a moderately successful career as an NFL journeyman.
I'm just saying, while hard work combined with talent can lead to elite performances, and hard work on its own will improve your skills no matter what level you're at, hard work alone is not a panacea if it's not matched with the ability to put a good suite of skills out there at the NFL level. Lots of guys worked hard and never got close to the pros.
I too like Hamilton. Guy looks like a chain mover. Miller haven’t studied him too much, his build looks similar to dj Moore, who I thinking is a Deion branch type comp
Similar build/size. Miller is a tough s.o.b. hes a faster/quicker Landry imo. Very physical, tough player that can work the middle, seems & like manx said hes a legit blocking WR.I too like Hamilton. Guy looks like a chain mover. Miller haven’t studied him too much, his build looks similar to dj Moore, who I thinking is a Deion branch type comp
Can Jackson rush the passer??
If the pats want him badly, they are going to have to trade ahead of Baltimore or Arizona who are looking QB as well.
Similar build/size. Miller is a tough s.o.b. hes a faster/quicker Landry imo. Very physical, tough player that can work the middle, seems & like manx said hes a legit blocking WR.
Moore btw is also excellent blocking. Hes younger & tested better than Ridley while putting up big time production with a acast of terrible QB's for years.
From our archive - this week all-time:
May 7 - May 22 (Through 26yrs)










