Once again this discussion has been about Chad PRE torn rotator cuff. Wow, you can't even keep up with the discussion. I don't care about his '08 wild card game, since he had already torn his rotator cuff. You know what else is ridiculous? The fact that you continue to use meaningless fantasy stats such, such as QB rating, that have been proven to be flawed to the point where BSPN has tried to create a better stat to measure Quarterbacks . QB rating includes yards, interceptions, touch downs, and completions and incompletions. Yards can be padded on by means of shovel pases, TE screens, bubble screens, and WR screens. You don't compare Quarterback's by means of yards. WR's can continually bail out or hurt their Quarterback's; Flacco's 2012 run is an example of a WR baoling out a Quarterback, thus inflating his passer rating in the process. tell me WHAT you thought of Pennington on the field. Don't give me meaningless fantasy stats. What did you think about his footwork? What did you think about his play under pressure?How good was he in your opinion before he tore his rotator cuff? Stats are meaningless if you didn't watch the games, or don't remember the games.