All things considered, Eli is the best quarterback in football. I would not have confidence that Brady would make that throw in that same situation anymore.
Not sure what's more hilarious the fact you think Eli Manning is the best quarterback in football or that Brady wouldn't have made a throw to a wide open receiver with no one around him for 5 yards while the defense didn't get any pressure whatsoever. Whether or not our receiver would catch it is a totally different story.