Poll: Hoyer or Stidham vs Denver?

[raduray]

Assuming Cam's not ready, who starts at QB against Denver?

 

[jmt57]

Obviously I am hoping Cam is cleared to play.

Given the performance of the other two versus the Chiefs, Stidham > Hoyer is the clear choice.

 

[Uptown]

Cam

 

[amfootball]

I think Hoyer. Bill trusts him for some reason.

 

[FreeTedWilliams]

Rohan Davey

 

[IllegalContact]

Hoyer is pointless

 

[Tottie]

Start Edelman and let Stidham run some routes.

 

[jah]

24 hours ago, I would have said Hoyer won the job over Stidham in a landslide in camp for a reason. Today, I'll be very upset if Hoyer starts another game. He was weakest in the only aspect we expected him to be strong at (intelligence/awareness). He has absolutely nothing to offer and honestly shouldn't even be wasting a roster spot.

 

[sean10mm]

Hoyer is pointless

I mean, that's kind of where I'm landing with this.

He has no upside - he had his extremely modest career peak like 5 years ago or something, and his given no evidence to suggest he's capable of a second act that even clears that low bar.

Stidhman at least theoretically could amount to something.

 

[IllegalContact]

I mean, that's kind of where I'm landing with this.

He has no upside - he had his extremely modest career peak like 5 years ago or something, and his given no evidence to suggest he's capable of a second act that even clears that low bar.

Stidhman at least theoretically could amount to something.

and we can find out if he isn't and move on if need be......they might both be a complete waste of time........bring kaepernick in

 

[Ras-IR Dowling]

I think Hoyer. Bill trusts him for some reason.

Trust was lost last night.

 

[Triumph]

Without question Hoyer.

He was 86ed because of 2 mental errors resulting in a 6 point missed opportunity.

 

[sb1]

0 votes for Hoyer. Yikes

 

[Triumph]

Vs KC

Hoyer 24 attempts - 15 completions - 130 yards - 62% completion rate - 0 TD - 1 INT - 2 Sacks. After Hoyer calmed down he made some very good throws and decisions. Hoyer was sailing balls in the beginning which led to the INT. A 62% completion rate is workable. The 2 costly mental mistakes resulting in 6 lost points did Hoyer in for the night, but they can be fixed.

Stidham 13 attempts - 5 completions - 38% completion rate - 1 TD - 2 INT - 0 Sacks. Some of his incompletions were dropped receptions just like with Hoyer. The INT in the endzone was brutal. Hoyer was locking on to Byrd. The Edelman INT needs to be caught, but the ball should have thrown at the numbers to where only your guy gets it or nobody does. Down by the goaline is a gift 7 points with not a prayer to tackle the defense from scoring.

 

[Ladypatsfan]

Neither should have been an option.

 

[PATSYLICIOUS]

I’d go with stidham. While both were a bit of a train wreck I’d say hoyer was worse. Stidham didn’t really goof until things were out of hand and we did not help him out. Each time he touched the ball he was trailing double digits, despite throwing a td on his first drive. Then the pick six through Edelman’s hands, not his fault imo put us in a 16 pt hole where he threw the bad pick. Hoyer had every opportunity to help us seize control of the game when the rest of the team was fighting their butt off and things were looking good and blew it repeatedly.

I think for better or for worse stidham should get a chance at 0-0 to prove himself. Hoyer has proven for years now that he can’t be counted on.

 

[Triumph]

When Dante Scarnechia stated Stidham would have growing pains we witnessed what DS was referring to last night.

Stidham had his shot waiting in the wings to supplant Hoyer as # 2.

 

[DaBruinz]

Hoyer shouldn't see the field again.

Hoyer cost this team a lot more than 6 points. He had a lot more than 2 mental errors. In fact, the last play of the half had 2 mental errors by itself. First was him taking the sack and the second was him attempting to call Time Out when they didn't have one.

 

[italian pat patriot]

I hope Cam has a chance otherwise Stidham

I was honestly destroyed after Hoyer performance

 

[sb1]

Neither should have been an option.

Well..they're our backups and I don't think there's any free agents out there who are much better.