I would agree with this. I think Guy is a nice rotational piece who has been playing over his head (kind of how I view LB Roberts, this year), but I think that his 2018 play is closer to “good” than it is to “mediocre,” that’s all. As we both pointed out, the bar is set pretty low, so perhaps that’s why he seems to be the best run stopper to me.
I would prefer a couple of higher round picks and a free agent pickup (or even two), which would improve the talent and reduce his role for 2019. That said, I do think that he’s been a solid pickup who has been providing good value.