Most receivers catch around 40%ish of 20+ balls. 72% is ridiculous.
What you fail to recognize, still, is the success that Maye to Boutte had caused defenses to devote deep coverage over the top. You aren’t getting that with Hollins.
But don’t take my word for it. Look at the film. Tell me how often you see Boutte running off coverage, pulling a corner and a safety over the top out of being able to cover the other receivers.
There is an enormous amount of value in that which you will never see in the stat sheet.
Even more, opponents watch film and see if you give Boutte a small amount of separation Maye is the best in the league at making the throw and Boutte is exceptional at tracking it and making the catch, often needing to go to the ground but holding on.
Stefon Diggs had eight games last year where he had a reception over 20 yards. Not sure how many of those games had multiple ones. Mack Hollins had six games where he had catches of 20 or more yards. Pop Douglas had six games with four of them over 37 yards. Hunter Henry had seven.
People had to worry about the Pats over the top because of Drake Maye, not Kayshon Boutte. Maye was the most accurate deep ball passer in the league last year and it wasn't just because of Boutte.
And stop it. Boutte had difficulties getting separation all year. He wasn't drawing extra coverage on a regular basis. If anyone got extra coverage, it Diggs.
If the tape showed that Boutte was getting a lot of double teams, it would mean all these other teams in the league thought he was a top WR. And if they felt that he needed consistent double teams, teams would have been falling over each other to trade for him. No team is thinking Boutte is such a dangerous deep ball threat that he needed double teams but then say to themselves that there is no way am they giving up even a sixth rounder for the guy.
I can see front offices now:
"Hey did you hear? The Pats are willing to trade Kayshon Boutte."
"Ah that guy gave us fits last year. We had to double team him all game. What are the Pats asking for him?"
" I think they will let him go for a sixth rounder."
"A sixth rounder?!? They are crazy if they think they will get that much. Pass."
Seriously, I wish Boutte was the receiver you thought he was. If he was, the Patriots would have given him a long term deal.