Ice_Ice_Brady
where black is the color where none is the number
- Joined
- Apr 3, 2006
- Messages
- 26,975
- Reaction score
- 53,345
I am over on the Saints board periodically. They have a really great board by the way. Lots of good football talk. But what Brady is doing with the records is killing them as the records were Brees' main stay to greatness and being ahead of the likes of Rodgers, Favre, Manning in their opinion. Being #2 really kind of nullifies that. LOL
That’s what I’ve been arguing for years about top 10 lists and legacies.
Statistical feats have no staying power. Number of games, passing attempts, passer rating passing yards, all go up to a new level and never come back down.
The efficiency/passer rating leaders are no exception. Aaron Rodgers is getting passed by Mahomes and Watson, so claims about his efficiency quickly become weak.
When Steve Young retired, he was considered to be the greatest or the co-GOAT because he was the high water mark. Then came Rodgers. Now comes Mahomes. But the big story is that these guys free fall from #1/2 to borderline top 10 and then even lower.
Same with big counting stats. Tarkenton, then Fouts, then Marino, then Favre, then Manning, then Brees. Each of these guys had, at the least, a “one of the greatest ever” moniker until getting surpassed.












