I acknowledge that there issues with Mac. But there are issues with every young QB, including Burrow and Allen. Mac isn’t getting help cleaning up those issues; that’s what coaches are for.
I agree that Judge probably hasn’t helped here. He was terrible with the Giants. But Patricia is not just a play caller, where he might barely be tolerable. As you said, the OL is inconsistent and that includes technique. That’s on MP; he’s the OL coach. Patricia changed blocking schemes and the playbook to dumb it down “for the players” and we see more mistakes than ever: dysfunctional routes, penalties, poor timing, etc. His changes seem like they were added to put his stamp on the offense (and to distinguish himself from Josh) and not to make it better. By dumbing it down, it’s become easier to defend.
Putting Bourne in the nearly permanent doghouse has been an unmitigated disaster; his absence might even have cost the Pats a win or two. Instead we see not ready for prime time Thornton. Screwing with Mac like he’s some dope has been a travesty. No fullback, tight ends who barely get involved in the Matty P “offense,” no cohesion or coherence. Matt Patricia is just one big unlikeable cluster*&$#. He’s the primary reason the offense has declined this year and every fan watching the game has been robbed of his or her viewing pleasure by that guy.