upstater1
Hall of Fame Poster
So, before the 2021 draft, I said I only liked Lawrence and Justin Fields. I had some harsh things to say about Zach Wilson, and really some very harsh things to say about Mac Jones (not as bad as what I said about Wilson). I think Mac won me over last year.
Jan 4, 2021
"Trey Lance and Zach Wilson are not top 5 or top 10 QBs. They are the type who go late in the first. I expect their stock will fall as we move into the combine/evaluation period. If BB passes on them, I am OK with that. He may actually grade them even lower than I do."
Jan 5, 2021
CONTEXT: Josh Allen was raw, small college, like Wilson and Lance
As it stands, this is what some team will HOPE to do with Justin Fields.
Given the short amount of time that Belichick will be here, I'd rather they bring in a vet like Garoppolo, Stafford or Wentz than try to develop guys that might not pan out--unless we're talking about Fields."
Jan 5, 2021
"The problem here is Wilson's competition. Passing in some of these leagues against defenses that have all the resistance of air. Watching highlights you see some of the passes from Wilson and Lance completed but you also notice the DBs moving at a snail's pace."
Jan 5, 2021
Jan 5, 2021
"They play incredibly weak competition. That's my main problem. So sure arm strength looks great. But against teams that don't pay defenses, you have wide open offenses throwing downfield. Where's the diversity in plays? They will have a lot to learn in the NFL. They are not polished. To me, a guy picked at the top of the 1st round is the kind of guy who should be starting at some point in his first year. I can't think of a single such QB who hasn't. Lance and Wilson are going to need a lot of development as opposed to Lawrence and Fields, who have so much of the pro game down already, of necessity because of the competition they play."
Jan 26, 2021
CONTEXT: Which conference has better QBs
Other poster: "This is a bizarre take. NFC has Rodgers, brady, wilson. Those 3 guys alone are better than anyone after Mahomes in the AFC. That's not taking into account guys like Matt ryan, Goff, Jimmy G who have made Superbowls and would immediately be upper QBs in the AFC. The fact the bills got demolished shows how far away they actually are. It's like when the allen iverson sixers would make it to the finals only to get destroyed by the Lakers because they didn't belong."
"I would definitely not take Kyler Murray over Josh Allen. Allen needs to develop his game but he has shown a lot this year. If he refines his game, he is the second best out there after Mahomes. The NFC guys are all older and soon to be phased out. I'd throw in with Watson, Allen, Herbert over ANY of the NFC guys. Trevor Lawrence to the Jags? He may be good too. Mayfield I'm not so sure about. Lamar Jackson is very interesting and could really develop but like Allen he needs refinement."
Feb 25, 2021
"The only position I feel I have a good eye for after almost 5 decades of watching is QB. I watched a lot of college ball and I really dont know what the Pro Scouts are looking for.
I like Fields a lot. Much better than Wilson.
But I saw Marino play practically every game when he was at Pitt and I wanted the Patriots to draft him so badly. We picked Eason??!?! I saw Favre light up the Senior Bowl and the guy was incredibly talented, easy to see. Same with Rodgers. As for Brady all he did was make the plays to beat my Nittany Lions.
In all the years I've banged the table on a top QB, I think I've only been wrong on Sam Bradford. I thought he was going to be fantastic."
Mar. 23, 2021
"Is is wrong if I don't want the Patriots taking a totally rich kid who won't necessarily connect with his teammates? I've read Wilson has displayed a sense of entitlement. I just don't want anyone with Jay Cuter's ability and Jay Cutler's demeanor."
Mar 26, 2021
"Is it me or is there a little bit a facial resemblance between Zach Wilson and Darnold? Darnold looks like a more mature Wilson:"
"
Jan 4, 2021
"Trey Lance and Zach Wilson are not top 5 or top 10 QBs. They are the type who go late in the first. I expect their stock will fall as we move into the combine/evaluation period. If BB passes on them, I am OK with that. He may actually grade them even lower than I do."
Jan 5, 2021
CONTEXT: Josh Allen was raw, small college, like Wilson and Lance
"[Allen] was the same. Except that he has exceptional size, and exceptional arm (much better than Wilson's), and he's a much better runner. If every team could take a QB like Wilson and make them into Josh Allen, they should do it.Josh Allen was the same. He didn’t fare well in some games but how’s he doing these days?
As it stands, this is what some team will HOPE to do with Justin Fields.
Given the short amount of time that Belichick will be here, I'd rather they bring in a vet like Garoppolo, Stafford or Wentz than try to develop guys that might not pan out--unless we're talking about Fields."
Jan 5, 2021
"The problem here is Wilson's competition. Passing in some of these leagues against defenses that have all the resistance of air. Watching highlights you see some of the passes from Wilson and Lance completed but you also notice the DBs moving at a snail's pace."
Jan 5, 2021
"What the ???? LOL. A little bit of a Rosen vibe there, but where the heck does that come from? I really don't like the lack of competition for judging Wilson. It's a problem. He may be an excellent QB down the road when he develops. But I hesitate to take him that high."On the negative side, they say Wilson is a rich, entitled brat who rather than being a leader, is a selfish know-it-all - his parents are a pain to deal with too.
Jan 5, 2021
"They play incredibly weak competition. That's my main problem. So sure arm strength looks great. But against teams that don't pay defenses, you have wide open offenses throwing downfield. Where's the diversity in plays? They will have a lot to learn in the NFL. They are not polished. To me, a guy picked at the top of the 1st round is the kind of guy who should be starting at some point in his first year. I can't think of a single such QB who hasn't. Lance and Wilson are going to need a lot of development as opposed to Lawrence and Fields, who have so much of the pro game down already, of necessity because of the competition they play."
Jan 26, 2021
CONTEXT: Which conference has better QBs
Other poster: "This is a bizarre take. NFC has Rodgers, brady, wilson. Those 3 guys alone are better than anyone after Mahomes in the AFC. That's not taking into account guys like Matt ryan, Goff, Jimmy G who have made Superbowls and would immediately be upper QBs in the AFC. The fact the bills got demolished shows how far away they actually are. It's like when the allen iverson sixers would make it to the finals only to get destroyed by the Lakers because they didn't belong."
"I would definitely not take Kyler Murray over Josh Allen. Allen needs to develop his game but he has shown a lot this year. If he refines his game, he is the second best out there after Mahomes. The NFC guys are all older and soon to be phased out. I'd throw in with Watson, Allen, Herbert over ANY of the NFC guys. Trevor Lawrence to the Jags? He may be good too. Mayfield I'm not so sure about. Lamar Jackson is very interesting and could really develop but like Allen he needs refinement."
Feb 25, 2021
"The only position I feel I have a good eye for after almost 5 decades of watching is QB. I watched a lot of college ball and I really dont know what the Pro Scouts are looking for.
I like Fields a lot. Much better than Wilson.
But I saw Marino play practically every game when he was at Pitt and I wanted the Patriots to draft him so badly. We picked Eason??!?! I saw Favre light up the Senior Bowl and the guy was incredibly talented, easy to see. Same with Rodgers. As for Brady all he did was make the plays to beat my Nittany Lions.
In all the years I've banged the table on a top QB, I think I've only been wrong on Sam Bradford. I thought he was going to be fantastic."
Mar. 23, 2021
"Is is wrong if I don't want the Patriots taking a totally rich kid who won't necessarily connect with his teammates? I've read Wilson has displayed a sense of entitlement. I just don't want anyone with Jay Cuter's ability and Jay Cutler's demeanor."
Mar 26, 2021
"Is it me or is there a little bit a facial resemblance between Zach Wilson and Darnold? Darnold looks like a more mature Wilson:"
"
Last edited: