Has Tim Tebow earned a roster spot on the Patriots?

[Joker]

Very true. You are allowed to smear people without repercussion, glad this is still the internet.

To each his own.

To which I would like to generically reply...as far as the Irish thing goes...

ERIN NO BRA!!!!!

 

[ATippett56]

Very true. You are allowed to smear people without repercussion, glad this is still the internet.

Which posters did I specifically call out?

I want names!

 

[Demosthenes]

Quite frankly, I don't have to do anything. :snob:

Apparently that includes trying to be at least somewhat honest in your posts.

 

[SDI_Gator]

Which posters did I specifically call out?

I want names!

I will not be doing your work for you.

:suspicious:

 

[Ironman44]

Quite frankly, I don't have to do anything. :snob:

Right cause your just making s*** up.

I do wonder what a stand up guy like Andre Tippett would think of your behavior.

 

[ATippett56]

Right cause your just making s*** up.

I do wonder what a stand up guy like Andre Tippett would think of your behavior.

So says one of the few posters on this message board who feels Tebow has "earned" a roster spot.

 

[Ironman44]

So says one of the few posters on this message board who feels Tebow has "earned" a roster spot.

I think tebow has sucked and is going to get cut. (I hope not)

keep making s*** up .....Tippett is watching.

 

[Demosthenes]

Those guys aren't really relevant in a conversation just about Welker but I'd say Lelei was underrated and underappreciated by the Broncos. McCareins was a good special teamer himself but Welker was better. Neither of those guys were complete like Welker. That attribute of Welker had in no way, shape or form anything to do with Brady. And YPC may matter less than those other two metrics but 67 catches is not a small sample size and 10.5 is still nothing to sneeze at at all.

Completely disagree that he was "made" in New England. I know that's a popular opinion but that doesn't make it so. And like I said if the Patriots felt that way they certainly wouldn't have given up a second round pick for him.

I made this statement about Welker

My position is that while he showed versatility while with the Phins, he didn't jump out and the page or give any indication that he'd be one of the most productive receivers in the NFL.

You replied with this:

You probably know he was a special teams dynamo with the Dolphins but as a receiver he did have 15.0 YPC in 2005 and 10.3 YPC in 2006. Both those numbers stand up to his stats as a Patriot. And that was with Harrington and Culpepper throwing to him. I actually think he might have been the best offensive weapon the Dolphins had in 2006....

There's a good reason why the Patriots were willing to cough up a second round pick for him.

The relevance of those guys is that all 3 of them had similar/better stats than Welker in 2005 yet none of them reached the superstar "elite" status that Welker attained.

That status is directly attributable to him coming here to NE where Brady was throwing the ball to him in an offense that ran through the slot.

Had Welker stayed in Miami or gone to most other teams in the NFL, he would have remained mired in mediocrity and would have been just as unknown as the three receivers that I mentioned.

 

[ATippett56]

I think tebow has sucked and is going to get cut. (I hope not)

keep making s*** up .....Tippett is watching.

You're a liar.

You voted yes in the poll.

 

[SDI_Gator]

I think tebow has sucked and is going to get cut.

keep making s*** up .....Tippett is watching.

What if he IS Andre Tippett?

 

[sb1]

It Is What It Is » Tim Tebow: ?Not worried? about his roster spot

He would appear to be safely on the roster for Thursday’s game against the Giants, the preseason finale at Gillette Stadium.

Still the question had to be asked of New England’s most famous back-up QB: Any sense of your fate?

“I’m just focused on today,” Tebow said with his typical smile.

Is this week any different?

“No.”

You don’t even think of what could be?

“No, just another game,” Tebow said. “You focus, not even on that game, but on preparing for that game. You focus on today, the install and getting ready for practice.”


Yep, Bill has taught him well.

 

[Ironman44]

You're a liar.

You voted yes in the poll.

Here you go this was post #57 below and explains why I voted yes and it had nothing to do with me thinking he earned jack s*** as I have said 2 dozen items in this thread alone.

I don't appreciate being called a liar but I am seeing a common thread between all the tebow detractors...its not exactly a bright group.

I picked yes because I am a fan of his and someone had to and I think its great we are adding yet ANOTHER poll !

Brilliant, the board needs about 9 more Tebow polls I think because 1 poll with 3000 responses was just not enough.

 

[ATippett56]

Apparently that includes trying to be at least somewhat honest in your posts.

Which posters did I specifically call out?

 

[Ironman44]

What if he IS Andre Tippett?

Mind almost blown but then I realized that as smart as Tippet was there is no way this person could be him.

 

[ATippett56]

Here you go this was post #57 below and explains why I voted yes and it had nothing to do with me thinking he earned jack s***

I don't appreciate being called a liar but I am seeing a common thread between all the tebow detractors...its not exactly a bright group.

Yet you voted yes in the poll.

 

[Demosthenes]

It Is What It Is » Tim Tebow: ?Not worried? about his roster spot

He would appear to be safely on the roster for Thursday’s game against the Giants, the preseason finale at Gillette Stadium.

Still the question had to be asked of New England’s most famous back-up QB: Any sense of your fate?

“I’m just focused on today,” Tebow said with his typical smile.

Is this week any different?

“No.”

You don’t even think of what could be?

“No, just another game,” Tebow said. “You focus, not even on that game, but on preparing for that game. You focus on today, the install and getting ready for practice.”


Yep, Bill has taught him well.

Nah, this was one thing Tebow already had down. Not that Bill isn't a master at it, or that it doesn't align with his philosophy, but that's classic Tebow.

 

[Ironman44]

Yet you voted yes in the poll.

yeah its called protesting a stupid poll.

keep rooting against a patriots player, it really looks good on you.

 

[SDI_Gator]

Nah, this was one thing Tebow already had down. Not that Bill isn't a master at it, or that it doesn't align with his philosophy, but that's classic Tebow.

Yep, Tebow has always been great with the media as far as saying a lot without actually saying anything.

Excited.

 

[Awesomo 3000]

Yet you voted yes in the poll.

"Gotcha!!"

 

[Demosthenes]

Which posters did I specifically call out?

Stop being disingenuous, as you aren't smart enough to pull it off.

Of course you didn't call out any person specifically, but you made statements like this:

[qipte]Don't tell that to some people because it's not a case of whether Tim Tebow has "earned" a roster spot, but because it's Tim Tebow he "deserves" a roster spot.
[/quote]


You can't point to a single person here who thinks that Tebow should be on the roster because he "deserves" a roster spot.

I can go back through your other blatherings vis a vis Tebow supporters and explain just how frakked up and intellectually dishonest those posts have been, but I'd just be repeating what I and others have already said, things that you have completely ignored.

(Ian and mods, sorry if this crosses the line, but this guy is being a total and complete dip**** and a liar to boot.)