Again, same devil's advocate question. We did not know in early November, the trade deadline, that he would be on the PUP list in December. We had no idea that the quad surgery would not, at least by our lights, have him ready now, 10 months later.
I mean, I'm no medical expert but ya gotta think your ability to get trade value is going to be contingent on him being the same guy once recovered. I am thinking that might not be the case.
Again, same question: If Bill Belichick sent a high draft pick somewhere for a guy who hasn't played since last November and cant get off the PUP list after surgery... would you be calling that stupid too? B/c that's what we're asking someone else to do - take a guy's healing for granted. B/c we haven't seen him on a field in 10 months.
(how lucky is this team, if every such head-scratcher can be answered with "what a dumb decision!" It's like they do nothing but dumb things and somehow won SBs for 20 years. )