Fantasy Football Playoffs QB selection

[VJCPatriot]

I have the following players and I can start 2 of them.

Vince Young - Jacksonville
Eli Manning - Philadelphia
Matt Leinart - Denver
Jeff Garcia - New York Giants

So who would you start and why?

 

[VrabelMayeWin]

I'd start Young. His scoring has been surprisingly consistent (and good) and he gives you sick upside, even against Jax.

 

[nukin]

I have the following players and I can start 2 of them.

Vince Young - Jacksonville
Eli Manning - Philadelphia
Matt Leinart - Denver
Jeff Garcia - New York Giants

So who would you start and why?

I would go with Young and Garcia. Garcia can surprise ya' sometimes.

 

[VrabelMayeWin]

I would go with Young and Garcia. Garcia can surprise ya' sometimes.

Oh, I didn't see that he needs to start two. Yeah, the Giants are 29th in the league in passing yards allowed, I'd go with Jeffey also.

 

[chris_in_sunnyvale]

Young and Garcia. I'm not thrilled with any of your matchups, but Young has been playing well lately, so go with the hot hand. Garcia has filled in admirably for McNabb, so I'd take him over Leinart vs. Denver's D and Eli who has been generally poor this past month.

Regards,
Chris

 

[nukin]

My roomate is in the playoff's as well as the 2nd seed, so it may be possible for me to play him.

Here is his lineup, which he starts every week without fail:
P. Manning QB
W. Dunn RB
L. Johnson RB
P. Burress WR
A. Johnson WR
A. Crumpler TE
J. Wilkins K
D. Ravens DST
Benched:
J. Kitna QB
M. Bell RB
B. Berrian WR
L. Coles WR
J. Scobee K

So far this year, he has the most PF and the least PA, which is silly because I beat him easy (105-49)... I have faith that my team is set for the playoffs. I just gotta beat the milestone that is LT and westbrook

 

[VJCPatriot]

Yup I only have LT and McGahee. I tried to upgrade from McGahee earlier in the season but everyone was afraid of me so I couldn't really pull off a deal.

Ok Now for Round 2.

This is for the Championship of the World!! OR at least of my league

This week I picked up Cutler and dropped Leinart so here are my choices.
(PS Last week's highest scoring combo would have been Eli + Garcia.)

Here are my QBs and the matchups:

Eli Manning - NO, 2588 passing yards allowed, 10 int, 36 sacks, 23 tds
Jay Cutler - Cin, 3383 passing yards allowed, 17 int, 31 sacks, 21 tds
Vince Young - Buff, 2622 passing yards allowed, 12 int, 39 sacks, 16 tds
Jeff Garcia - Dal, 3007 passing yards allowed, 16 int, 27 sacks, 20 tds

I did play Vince Young last week but I got burned and I'm lucky I didn't lose because of him. Guess that youth means inconsistency. But Cutler looked good so I thought I'd give him a looksee. I'm afraid to start such a raw rookie but he passed for over 250 yards with 2 tds last week.

Ok let's hear it guys. Your picks and reasons please.

PS Am I crazy or does it look like Cutler could carve up the Cinci D?

 

[chris_in_sunnyvale]

Garcia and Young again. Eli is unreliable at this point. I wouldn't trust Cutler. Young might score two TDs with his feet against the Bills. Good luck in your title game. Wish me luck in mine.

Regards,
Chris

 

[scout]

I can't stand fantasy football, but whats worse was that idiot selling his **** on our forum. Got tired of seeing it, thus my post

 

[Terry Glenn is a cowgirl]

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...

 

[patsfanofNC12]

Young and Garcia no question. Eli and Matt just aren't good (as of right now).