I bet Marino would trade some of the records he retired with and has since been passed for a ring.
While Manning will retire as the statistically better quarterback, Rodgers will retire ahead of him. Rodgers is ahead of Peyton (and Brady) in passer rating, yards per attempt, adjusted yards per attempt, net adjusted yard per attempt, and touchdown percentage. They both have 1 SB. It's a passing era and will continue to be. Look at Marino. He won't be top 5 in passing yards or td's by the time Brady Brees and Rodgers are done.
Brady has played about well enough to win 5 super bowls. Manning, just one. Brady has not always been stellar, but has been one defensive stop away from victory in his two losses. Manning got blown out, and threw a game sealing pick-6 in the other.