PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Consensus Big Board - Preseason Rankings

mayoclinic

PatsFans.com Supporter
PatsFans.com Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2008
Messages
23,354
Reaction score
17,224
Not much to discuss these days. Things will ramp up in a few weeks.

I feel like we're ahead of last year in terms of beating the trees to shake out prospects of interest. I was looking at the Consensus Big Board to see how players stack up.

Offense:

I want to focus on defense in 2027, but there may be some values on offense, especially at TE and IOL.

QB:

1. Arch Manning, Texas
2. Dante Moore, foregone
7. Darian Mensah, Miami
12. Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma St.
15. Julian Sayin, Ohio St.
22. LaNorris Sellers, S. Carolina
24. CJ Carr, Notre Dame
39. Jordan Maiava, USC
48. Drake Lindsey, Minnesota
59. Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss
75. Brendan Sorsby, Texas Tech
77. CJ Bailey, N. Carolina
108. Sam Leavitt, LSU
125. John Mateer, Oklahoma
141. Josh Hoover, Indiana
182. Will Hammond, Texas Tech
185. DJ Lagway, Baylor
257. Nico Iamaleava, UCLA

My Thoughts:

The more the merrier. I hope a ton of QBs go early, pushing more non-QB prospects to the Pats.

6-7 first round QBs definitely possible. Manning and Moore are locks. Mestemaker and Lindsey have size and arms. Maiava, Bailey, Sorsby and Iamaleava are toolsy. Carr, Sayin and Mensah will get lots of spotlight. Sellars, Mateer and Chambliss are wildcards to me.

Not a position for NE unless a very talented guy with upside slips to round 6 or later. That will only happen if there are major red flags (Sorsby, Iamaleava).


RB:

30. Kewan Lacy, Ole Miss
42. Ahmad Harvey, Missouri
43. Jaden Baugh, Florida
73. Isaac Brown, Louisville
100. LJ Martin, BYU
107. Antwan Raymond, Rutgers
112. Mark Fletcher, Miami
117. Raleek Brown, Texas
119. Nate Frazier, Georgia
144. Hollywood Smothers, Texas
154. Justice Haynes, Georgia Tech

My Thoughts:

This is a much deeper group than 2026, though there is no Jeremiyah Love at the top.

Baugh, Lacy and Hardy are the clear top 3 - in that order, IMO. Baugh a perfect complement to TreVeyon Henderson, but I wouldn't invest the draft capital on RB that high. Hardy's lack of receiving ability limits him. Brown very intriguing.

Some good mid round options if any slip to round 5 or later, but wouldn't go RB before then. I like Mark Fletcher and Nate Frazier. Justice Haynes very under-valued.


WR:

3. Jeremiah Smith, Ohio St.
8. Cam Coleman, Texas
25. Nick Marsh, Indiana
29. Charlie Becker, Indiana
31. Ryan Coleman-Williams, Alabama
32. Omarion Miller, Arizona St.
41. Ryan Wingo, Texas
49. Mario Craver, Texas A&M
57. KJ Duff, Rutgers
67. Bryant Wesco. Clemson
68. Wyatt Young, OklahomaDy.
72. TJ Young, Clemson
86. Mike Mathews, Tennessee
95. Nyck Harbor, S. Carolina
131. Junior Sherrill, Vanderbilt
161. Tre Richardson, Louisville
167. Evan Stewart, Oregon
256. Nyziah Hunter, Nebraska
265. Duce Robinson, FloridaSt.
273. Eric Dingleton, Florida
282. Amare Yhomas, Houston
289. Cooper Barkate, Miami


My Thoughts:

Jeremiah Smith and Cam Coleman are better than any WRs since 2024. Charlie Becker and Nick Marsh would be great fits for NE, but I do not want to fraft a WR before day 3.

Nyziah Hunter, Duce Robinson and Eric Singleton very under-rated. But overall, 2026 was a deeper group.


TE:

16. Jamari Johnson, Oregon
38. Trey'Dez Green, LSU
63. Andrew Rappleyea, Penn St.
84. Peter Clarke, Temple
140. Theo Melin Ohrstom, SMU
192. Brett Norfleet, Missouri
228. Alex Honig, Northwestern
303. Lawson Luckie, Georgia

My Thoughts:

One of the only offensive positions I would consider before day 3, if the value is there. TEs are Queens on the offensive chessboard, and the league is finally figuring it out. TEs were prized in the 2026 draft, and I expect that to continue in 2027, with a copycat league using more 12 and 13 personnel.

Jamari Johnson is the prize. I like him much better than Kenyon Sadiq. Trey'Dez Green could be a Jimmy Graham kind of weapon, Kyle Pitts at the least. Andrew Rappleyea seems to be emerging as the clear #3 prospect for now - Sam Teets has him at #13 overall. Peter Clarke is the most intriguing Y TE; he will be a difficult eval coming out if Temple, and testing will get key.

Beyond them, there are a bunch of solid guys, with a variety of skill sets. Benjamin Brahmer, DJ Vonhamme, Chris Corbo and Terrance Carter all intriguing. But not nearly as deep a group as 2026.


OT:

9. Jordan Seaton, LSU
10. Trevor Goosby, Texas
23. Cayden Green, Missouri*
28. Austin Siereveld. Ohio St.*
37. Carter Smith, Indiana*
46. Trevor Lauck, Iowa
55. Jacarrius Peak, S. Carolina
69. Anthonie Knapp, Notre Dame*
79. PJ Williams, SMU
94. Melvin Siani, Texas
96. Lance Heard, Kentucky
101. Samson Okunlola, Miami*
103. Niki Prongos, Stanford
104. Blake Frazier, Michigan
111. Anthony Donkoh, Penn St.
126. McKale Boley, Virginia*
137. Ian Moore, Ohio St.
159. Drew Azzopardi, Washington
166. Desmeal Lee, Youngstown St.
170. Ryan Baer, Pittsburgh
181. Xavier Chaplin, Florida St.
253. Andrew Sprague, Michigan
262. Elijah Paige, USC
301. Elijah Pritchett, Nebraska
322. Ernest Greene, Georgia
381. Nathan Roy, Minnesota
739. Wilkin Foby, Texas A&M
798. Kolt Dieterich, Washington

* Projects to IOL

My Thoughts:

I don't want to draft an OT unless (1) it is a tackle->guard conversion, or (2) Will Campbell moves inside.

Jordan Seaton and Trevor Goosby are up with Monroe Freeling as ultra-athletic pure tackles. Both will go top 15. After them, the 2027 tackle class is not as deep at the top as 2026. There are many players who project inside at the next level.

Jacarrius Peak and PJ Williams are highly athletic prospects who I think could play either tackle or guard at the next level.

Niki Prongos is my pure OT3. He, along with Ian Moore, Blake Frazier, Elijah Paige, and Elijah Pritchett could be huge risers as true OTs. Also Nathan Roy, though I thought he was a true sophomore. Desmeal Leigh and Kolt Dieterich wild cards. Trevor Lauck my OT4 - very steady and technically sound. Melvin Siani also steady, a potential riser.


IOL:

23. Cayden Green, Missouri*
28. Austin Siereveld. Ohio St.*
35. Kade Pieper, Iowa
37. Carter Smith, Indiana*
55. Jacarrius Peak, S. Carolina*
66. Greg Johnson, Minnesota
69. Anthonie Knapp, Notre Dame*
76. Iapani Laloulu, aoregon
79. PJ Williams, SMU*
97. Evan atengesdahl, Cincinnati
102. Charles Jagusah, Notre Dame
110. Brandon Baker, Texas
123. Ezomo Oratokhai, Northwestern
158. Luke Montgomery, Ohio St.
278. Drew Bobo, Georgia
305. Justin Evans, Nebraska

* Currently plays OT

My Thoughts:

IOL and TE are the 2 offensive positions that I would be ok investing in before day 3, if the value is there. Completing the OL buildout should be a priority. That said, I would probably prefer to address both in FA if the opportunity arises, and devote 2027 to infusing the defense with young talent.

Jacarrius Peak, Ezomo Oratokhai and PJ Williams are my top 3 right now based on their athleticism. Oratokhai is a RS Sophomore but reportedly is 24. Peak s coming off a knee injury. Kade Pieper is incredibly athletic. Charles Jagusah is in a class by himself - maybe the most upside, but a complete enigma.

Austin Siereveld, Carter Smith, Cayden Green, Brandon Baker and Anthonie Knapp are all T -> G conversions. All should be very good. I'm not sure any is a clear 1st round talent, but testing may help differentiate them. Greg Johnson is a highly versatile option as well.


Defense:

This is where I hope the Pats spend the vast majority of their 2027 draft capital.


IDL:

11. David Stone, Oklahoma
14. A'Mauri Washington, Oregon
19. Justin Scott, Miami
21. Ahmad Moten, Miami
45. Will Echoles, Ole Miss
53. AJ Holmes, Texas Tech
71. Mateen Ibirogba, atexas Tech
78. Bear Alexander, Oregon
82. Anthony Smith, Minnesota
113. James Smith, Ohio St.
118. Jayden Jackson, Oklahoma
128. Tavion Gadsen, Kentucky
136. Mario Landino, Indiana
147. Stephiylan Green, LSU

My Thoughts:

This is a really good group at the top. The top 5 could all be in the BPA conversation for the Pats.

David Stone and Justin Scott will vie for the top 3-Tech. Both very talented and explosive. Mateen Ibirogba doesn't have as complete a game yet, but his game is so disruptive

A'Mauri Washington and Will Echoles are more 1-Techs who can also penetrate, both 1st round caliber. Echoles is still very under-rated right now.

AJ Holmes, Tavion Gadsen, Jayden Jackson and Stephiylan Green are sleepers to watch.

2026 had some ridiculous late round highly athletic DTs: Jordan Van den Berg, Rene Konga, DaMonte Capehart. Not to mention Uar Bernard. I don't see those kind of guys just yet.


EDGE:

4. Dylan Stewart, S. Carolina
6. Collin Simmons, Texas
20. Matayo Uiagalelei, Oregon
27. Quincy Rhodes, Arkansas
36. Damon Wilson, Miami
44. Kenyatta Jackson, Ohio St.
47. Princewill Unmanmielen, LSU
54. Jordan Ross, LSU
58. John Henry Daley, Michigan
60. Yhonzae Pierre, Alabama
64. Boubacar Traore, Notre Dame
70. Teitum Tuioti, Oregon
80. Will Heldt, Clemson
81. Clev Lubin, Louisville
83. Taylor Wein, Oklahoma
94. Anto Saka, Texas A&M
115. Bryce Young, Notre Dame
197. Adam Trick, Texas Tech
220. Elijah Rushing, Oregon
240. Kameryn Crawford, USC
284. Jonathan Maldonado, Ole Miss
299. Trey White, Texas Tech
334. Williams Nwanwri, Nebraska
1000. Melkart Abou Jaoude, N. Carolina

My Thoughts:

Stewart and Simmons are elite talents. I think Yhonzae Pierre and Jordan Ross are the other 2 guys with the athleticism and speed/speed-to-power to potentially be 1st round talents. Beyond them, Boubacar Traore and Clev Lubin are intriguing day 2 prospects who would fit well.

The others don't interest me much. Uiagalelei, Rhodes, Jackson and Heldt are all power DEs who don't offer much over DreMont Jones. Taylor Heim, Anto Saka, Bryce Young and Adam Trick worth watching. Not sure about Damon Wilson or John Henry Daley.

Right now my list of intriguing EDGE prospects is pretty short. I'm more interested in the other defensive positions.


LB:

34. Sammy Brown, Clemson
40. Kyngstonn Viliamu-asa, Notre Dame
61. Chris Sullivan, Oklahoma
74. Rasheem Biles, Texas
91. Ben Roberts, Texas Tech
99. Christian Alliegro, Ohio St.
106. Suntarine Perkins. Ole Miss
120. Ray Coney, Texas A&M
142. Austin Romaine, Yrxas Tech
200. Whit Weeks, LSU
231. Chris Cole, Georgia
233. Isaiah Glasker, BYU
239. Owen Heinecke, Oklahoma
285. Tony Rojas, Penn St.
295. Xavier Atkins. Auburn
307. Raylen Wilson, Georgia
316. Arion Carter, Tennessee
692. Sammy Omosighbo, UCLA

My Thoughts:

LB is a prime area of need for the Pats - both MIKE and WILL/SAM - and is seriously undervalued right now.

Sammy Brown, Kyngstonn Viliamu-asa, and #231 Chris Cole are the clear top 3 for me, all 1st round talents. I want one of those 3 to be a Patriot in 2027. Brown could be better than Jacob Rodriguez or CJ Allen. Cole already gets Arvell Reese comps, and I expect him to have a meteoric rise. KVA is coming off an ACL injury, but somewhat similar to Chris Cole. Any could be BPA in late round 1.

Rasheem Biles, Chris Sullivan, Christian Alliegro and Suntarine Perkins don't interest me much at this point. Ben Roberts is a great WILL option, and Ray Coney is my #2 MIKE after Sammy Brown.

Xavier Atkins a possible S convert? Great tape

Arion Carter, Whit Weeks, Isaiah Glasker, Tony Rojas and Sammy Omosighbo all very undervalued right now.

A double dip at LB is a definite possibility.


S:

17. KJ Bolden, Georgia
18. Bruntae Johnson, Notre Dame
50. Koi Perich, Oregon
85. Jaylen McClain, Ohio St.
87. Jelani McDonald, Texas
88. Zach Lutmer, Iowa
89. Xavier Scott, Illinois
90. Marcus Neal, Penn St.
92. Bray Hubbard, Alabama
122. Jackson Bennee, Utah
124. Ty Benefield, LSU
127. Dashawn Spears, LSU
146. Tao Johnson, UCLA
151. Zachariah Poyser, Miami
162. Keon Sabb, Alabama
267. Xavier Lucas, Miami
280. Terry Moore, Ohio St.
465. Faletau Satuala, BYU
793. Amare Ferrell, Indiana
999. Rod Moore, Michigan

My Thoughts:

KJ Bolden, Tae Johnson and Jelani McDonald are the clear top 3 for me, all top 40 talents, comparable to last year's Caleb Downs (12), Dillon Thieneman (25) and Treydan Stukes (38). McDonald is way under-rated at 87, and would be a steal day 2 if he falls in that range, but I expect him to do a Stukes-like rise.

Koi Perich, Zach Lutmer, and Jaylen McClain and Xavier Scott are intriguing. Perich is a little over-rated for me right now but has potential. Lutmer is a bit of a poor man's Cooper DeJean. McClain reportedly has 4.35 speed and great range.

Ty Benefield, Jackson Bennee, Dashawn Spears and Tao Johnson are all potential risers. Amare Ferrell and Rod Moore are way under the radar, and have top-100 talent. I have Xavier Lucas as a corner, but he's another dark horse worth watching.

I would love to see the Pats grab a rangy safety in rounds 3-5 to pair with Craig Woodson. Safeties are undervalued, and some will slip through the cracks. Jelani McDonald is my binky, though I think he will go high, but there are lots of intriguing guys.


CB:

5. Leonard Moore, Notre Dame
13. Ellis Robinson IV, Georgia
26. Zabien Brown, Alabama
33. Kelley Jones, Mississippi St.
51. Ashton Hampton, Clemson
52. OJ Frederique, Miami
56. Jamari Sharpe, Indiana
62. Chris Peal, Syracuse
65. Brice Pollack, Texas Tech
129. Jontez Williams, USC
132. DJ McKinney, Notre Dame
139. Elijah Green, Tulsa
148. Jyaire Hill, Michigan
153. Jayden Bellamy, UCF
179. Jermaine Matthews, Ohio St.
187. AJ Harris, Indian
242. Ja'Bril Rawls, Florida St.
267. Xavier Lucas, Miami (listed at S)
268. Dezz Ricks, Texas A&M
300. Vicari Swain, S. Carolina
369. Demello Jones, Georgia

My Thoughts:

Finding a long-term #2 opposite Christian Gonzalez to succeed Carlton Davis should be one of the top priorities for 2027. CB is valued higher than S, and the CB pool is not as deep. This could be a 1st round area if a top talent slips, but I think 2nd round is more likely.

Leonard Moore and Ellis Robinson IV will be out of reach - Moore will be in the Gonzo/Surtain/Stingley class. But one of Ashton Hampton, Kelly Washington, OJ Frederique, Brice Pollack and #369 Demello Jones should slip into day 2 and could be a good complement to Gonzo. Demello Jones is way off the radar right now, but with a good season he will rise fast.

Elijah Green, Jayden Bellamy, Dezz Ricks, Jyaire Hill, Ja'Bril Rawls and Xavier Lucas are other sleepers to watch.
 
This is a lot of information. I put the individual positional rankings and my thoughts under each positional thread, as well.
 
In 4-6 weeks will will start to have useful information like Dane Brugler's early top 50 and Bruce Feldman's freaks list. It will be interesting to compare.
 

PatsFans.com LinkHub

📰 Article
media0.giphy.com
Uncategorized
media0.giphy.com · by PATSNUTme
4h
📰
📰 Article
Patriots DC Zak Kuhr's Motivation Stems From Two Important Things
Uncategorized
si.com · by mayoclinic
2d
𝕏 / Tweet
Post from @LosTalksPats on X: Raekwon McMillan Announced His Retirement Today
Patriots News
x.com · by Ian
3d
📰
📰 Article
Top 100 NFL players of 2026: Myles Garrett tops rankings as Rams boast three players in top 10
Interesting Article (Sports)
cbssports.com · by Rob0729
3d
▶ YouTube
Mack Hollins is putting in WORK ???? #patriots #nfl #shorts
Patriots Videos
youtube.com · by Ian
3d
📰
📰 Article
2026 NFL Preview: Changing Face of the Modern NFL Defense - AOL
Interesting Article (Sports)
aol.com · by mayoclinic
3d
📰
📰 Article
Troy Brown worked his way into Hall
Player Info Link
bostonherald.com · by jmt57
3d
Patriots News 07-05, Positions That Still Need More Depth
MORSE: Patriots Position Breakdown, QBs and Tight Ends
Patriots News 06-28: Romeo Doubs The Patriots X Factor?
MORSE: Patriots Position Breakdown – RB
Patriots News 06-20: The Not-So-Ideal Jacas Situation
MORSE: Looking At Patriots Wide Receiver Room and Gabe Jacas Mess
Key Questions Remain After Patriots Mini Camp: Little Margin For Error at Several Positions
Patriots News 06-14, Patriots Wrap Up Spring Workouts
Patriots Rookie Lomu Reveals “Weird” First Days at Right Tackle
Vrabel’s Goal For Christian Barmore in 2026: “Being able to finish”
Back
Top