Brady is the best QB ever

[JMC00]

Guy is literally 2 plays away from being 6-0 in the SB.

 

[wolverinejoe80]

Montana is so overrated it's not even funny. it's a team game and he had a stacked team. niners were like this pats + seahawks + jerry rice put together. they beat a team 55-10!!! that's like playing tebow's broncos in the SB!!

I've said this many times - Brady's been the GOAT since 18-1 season. nobody did more with less.

having said all that it won't hurt to win the 5th.

 

[PatsFanInVa]

Guy is literally 2 plays away from being 6-0 in the SB.

And 1 play away from being 3-3... I guess he's got a large enough sample size for those things to even out at least a little.

But damn, that catch made me want to cry. The tears just didn't have enough time to get out before Butler snagged that ball!

 

[Afam]

Peyton Manning Who ? . That debate has finally been settled. 4 Super Bowl Rings to 1. Clutch in the Post Season Verus Peyton who always chokes when the moment gets too big. Case Closed.

 

[SHOWTIME15]

Montana is so overrated it's not even funny. it's a team game and he had a stacked team. niners were like this pats + seahawks + jerry rice put together. they beat a team 55-10!!! that's like playing tebow's broncos in the SB!!

I disagree completely. He did play on a great team, but is an amazing QB. And it's an era of parity now, so you won't see too many 55-10 blowouts any more unless the broncos are involved.

 

[spo]

How are his stats versus Jaguars and Raiders? According to ESPN this is what gives Manning the leade

 

[Ring 6]

It is now time for the Brady GOAT case

Now that he has ring #4 and 3 of the MVP that matters trophies he no longer sits behind Montana.
Both after 15 years in the league by the way.

SB Championships
Brady 4
Montana 4

Conference Championships
Brady 6
Montana 4

Playoff Records
Brady 21-8
Montana 16-7

Playoff One and Dones
Brady 2
Montana 4

Playoff TD/Int
Brady 53/26
Montana 45/21

Playoff Passing Yards Per Game
Brady 253.3
Montana 251.0


Regular Season

Win/loss
Brady 160-47
Montana 117-47
(yes, Brady has 43 more wins to the same number of losses)

Att/Comp/%
Brady 7168/4551/63.5%
Montana 5391/3409/63.2%

Yards
Brady 53,258
Montana 40,551

Touchdowns
Brady 392 5.5%
Montana 273 5.1%

Interceptions
Brady 143 2.0%
Montana 139 2.6%

Passer Rating
Brady 95.9
Montana 92.3



I don't think there is really any doubt that Tom Brady is the GOAT.

 

[rfh]

Amazingly, a lot of people feel that this one only puts Brady in the conversation of GOAT, like he wasn't even in the conversation prior to this win. There are a ton of people that feel Montana is still the best because of how the game was played back then with QB's getting legally and viciously hammered all the time, plus the fact it took Brady 6 times to get his 4 rings

I just don't get it. Brady should be the undisputed GOAT now, and arguably the GOAT prior to this win, but I'm sure even if the Pats win another one, w/Brady at the helm, there would still be some who wouldn't agree he's the best

Side note: Brady should hand the keys to that truck he won over to Butler. That would be a great gesture.

 

[RelocatedPatFan]

No doubt.................

you make it seem like it was ever in any doubt.

 

[meatface]

I wonder how long it took for Giselle to jump his bones after this game

 

[meatface]

Amazingly, a lot of people feel that this one only puts Brady in the conversation of GOAT, like he wasn't even in the conversation prior to this win. There are a ton of people that feel Montana is still the best because of how the game was played back then with QB's getting legally and viciously hammered all the time, plus the fact it took Brady 6 times to get his 4 rings

I just don't get it. Brady should be the undisputed GOAT now, and arguably the GOAT prior to this win, but I'm sure even if the Pats win another one, w/Brady at the helm, there would still be some who wouldn't agree he's the best

Side note: Brady should hand the keys to that truck he won over to Butler. That would be a great gesture.

It is funny how many people use the fact that Brady lost two as a justification for why Montana is better, I mean I would think going to the Super bowl would count for a a little

 

[libra957]

In my eyes there is no more debate, Tom Brady is now the best ever!

 

[festy1986]

Tom Brady is the best qb I've seen since joe montainya

 

[Bruins29]

Tom Brady is the best qb I've seen since joe montainya

 

[BradyFTW!]

It is funny how many people use the fact that Brady lost two as a justification for why Montana is better, I mean I would think going to the Super bowl would count for a a little

They're the same people who think that Manning belongs in the conversation. One and dones are apparently better than Super Bowl losses to them.

 

[RecoveringCowboy]

One of the most absurd sour grapes post I've seen is a Cowboy saying Peyton is better than Tom, even after I gently asked about playoffs. Of course, I could have replied Romo is a younger Peyton.

 

[Deus Irae]

Montana is so overrated it's not even funny.

No, he's not.

 

[Deus Irae]

Brady v. Manning is now over

Brady v. Montana will go on for years

 

[BritPat]

Anyone even thinking Montana is over-rated, let alone posting it in public, should be locked up for life.

 

[wolverinejoe80]

I disagree completely. He did play on a great team, but is an amazing QB. And it's an era of parity now, so you won't see too many 55-10 blowouts any more unless the broncos are involved.

he is great and he is definitely the 2nd best QB in my life time, but the way some people think he is 'untouchable' because he went 4 for 4 in the SB makes me sick.

brady has done more with less, played in an era where defense is more complex than ever, played against much faster and bigger players, accumulated more stats, and went to 2 more SBs.

so i really am tired of 'but montana went 4 for 4' argument. that's just ******ed.