Don't say this out loud. All the "Franchise Cassel" folks are in denial about a couple of facts:
1. Franchising Cassel takes away $15 million of our cap space, until he is traded, which might not happen immediately if his agent is a tough bargainer.
2. Our players who become FAs next year will hit the market March 1. We will have to try to sign our FAs and sign other team's FAs using only the cap money remaining after the $15 mil Cassel hit.
3. Signing without a big cap space will be tough because you can no longer pro-rate a signing bonus for the entire length of the contract. Most of the money is taken off the cap this year.
4. By the time Cassel is traded, our best FAs would have had a taste of big dollars in Free Agency and may have already signed with other teams. We can't franchise them while working out a deal because we are using the tag on Cassel.
5. It isn't even a certainty that Cassel can be traded if he is franchised. If he doesn't like the team or what they are offering, he simply refuses to sign a long term deal with that team and kills the trade.
But still the cry is, "It's a no brainer. We should franchise Cassel." Actually, I agree with the no brainer part of the idea
Chance losing our own FAs and lose the ability to sign otehr FAs to try to get a first or second round pick, when we'll get a 3rd round pick by losing him to FA anway? Sure.
Funny thing is, the folks crying loudest to not let Cassel go are the ones who were screaming to cut him last September.
My thoughts on your points.
1.) The $14 mil to $15 mil in cap space the Pats momentarily lose should not pose a big problem, because the Pats always seem to take a long term view on things and acquiring a 1st or 2nd Rd pick for a former 7th Rd pick is good business.
2.) With the exception of Cassel none of our FA's are big money guys. Here are the restricted and unrestricted FA's for 2009.
RFAs: Eric Alexander, Wesley Britt and Pierre Woods.
UFA's: Matt Cassel, Heath Evans, Jabar Gafney, Chris Hanson, Rodney Harrison, Russ Hochstein, Larry Izzo, LaMont Jordan, Detha O'Neal, Lonie Paxton, James and Lewis Sanders, Tank Williams and Mike Wright. There's certainly some players in FA I'd like the Pats to go after but with the exception of Nnamdi Asomugha, Albert Haynesworth and Karlos Dansby no one I would throw big $ at.
3.) Franching Cassel would be a 1 yr deal.
4.) Irrelevant, you can't let a QB get away for nothing in this league, especially one you developed for 4 yrs. It's a QB driven league and without a guality player under center teams are not succesful so they will pay for quality.
5.) Once again, it's a QB driven league and teams will step up to acquire him. Think Matt Schaub, Rob Johnson, Scott Mitchell, etc. players that had much less experience and got big $ deals. I'm also sure Cassel would go to any team via trade that needs a starting QB, same as he would in FA. A team with a legitimate starting QB would certainly not go after him.
It's ok to disagree on things, I'm sure some think it's a good idea to franchise Cassel, while others don't. We'll see what happens after the season but for now let's enjoy the final two games and hopefully we get into the playoffs.