- Joined
- Dec 21, 2007
- Messages
- 27,134
- Reaction score
- 22,132
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.I thought this game was better than last. Noticed some good use of Hoyer on the sidelines.Found the incessant chatter between Zo and the McCourty twins insufferable.
They do not announce the game, unfortunately.
Very difficult to watch with the current style of the announcers.
Chism is much more consistent than K. Williams.
Wiliams hasn’t shown any ability as a WR except his release on a go ball but the guy can’t run a route to save his life.
Did you actually watch the game?It’s Tyquan all over again sort of. Speed is blinding people.
Speed doesn’t do you good if the only thing you can do is running straight.
I don’t know how Williams will see the field in the regular season. A.J Brown, Doubs, Boutte and Hollins are all in front of him. Douglas is a pure slot so Williams won’t take his spot.
if it was me, I would keep Chism over Williams because he is the only backup slot. I don’t think Williams will matter with how little he will see the field.
The original plan IMO was to draft Williams and hope that he was gonna be good enough to replace Boutte this year. But he clearly isn’t.
Kinda. Interior OL depth was a concern but they signed Van Roten to fix that, but since he didn’t see the field, and Ben Brown is also still out, the “fix” was not apparent. So while the “2s” were out there to start the game against Philly’s second string, in reality they were playing something like their 5th and 6th best guards. In all likelihood none of the guys who played guard in this game will make the team.Everyone has depth in someplaces and not others. What are the most worrisome positions? OL has to be one right?
Thing is, Williams has shown more than pure straightline speed. There have been lots of comments about his nasty release, and if you take a close look at it they’re deserved. Plus I’ve seen him do the same quick lateral moves in the middle of the route.It’s Tyquan all over again sort of. Speed is blinding people.
Speed doesn’t do you good if the only thing you can do is running straight.
You’re right. That’s why Boutte is a problem. He’s too good to cut outright, but he’s in the way of developing Williams who has three more years on his cheap rookie contract. From what I’ve seen so far this preseason I’m not sure Williams is much behind Boutte even now, other than seniority.I don’t know how Williams will see the field in the regular season. A.J Brown, Doubs, Boutte and Hollins are all in front of him. Douglas is a pure slot so Williams won’t take his spot.
It’s not clear to me that he clearly isn’t. Boutte has the advantage of a larger body of work in the regular season. But he’s also in his fourth season in the league when Williams is in his second. I think you’re right that the plan was to draft Williams to replace Boutte, but not this year rather when Boutte’s rookie contract expires and he leaves in FA next year. But that was before we developed a logjam at WR.if it was me, I would keep Chism over Williams because he is the only backup slot. I don’t think Williams will matter with how little he will see the field.
The original plan IMO was to draft Williams and hope that he was gonna be good enough to replace Boutte this year. But he clearly isn’t.
It’s Tyquan all over again sort of. Speed is blinding people.
Speed doesn’t do you good if the only thing you can do is running straight.
I don’t know how Williams will see the field in the regular season. A.J Brown, Doubs, Boutte and Hollins are all in front of him. Douglas is a pure slot so Williams won’t take his spot.
if it was me, I would keep Chism over Williams because he is the only backup slot. I don’t think Williams will matter with how little he will see the field.
The original plan IMO was to draft Williams and hope that he was gonna be good enough to replace Boutte this year. But he clearly isn’t.
Thanks for that. I’ve noticed him a couple of times, hadn’t yet looked into his background. Appreciate the info you found and shared.I've been doing some research on Amari Gainer because he's stood out to me the last couple of games and it's quite interesting.
As I’ve been looking at possible players to get in a swap for Boutte I started liking Logan Hall from the Texans, because he’s listed at edge and the Texans have some depth there and also because SI reports they’re also working him at LB. So I’m interested in in seeing if we might keep Gainer since we already have him in house and from his RAS he seems athletic enough. And he’s shown up making At least a few plays on the field.He spent 4 years at Florida State and two years at UNC (at the same time as Maye).
Interestingly he was largely an off ball linebacker there, predominently playing WILL but also MIKE on Occasion. In his last year at FSU, he had almost 3 times as many snaps as a linebacker than he did an EDGE rusher. In his last year at UNC those numbers were reversed and he became much more of an edge rusher.
He had an outstanding forty at his pro day of 4.52. The rest of his numbers while not elite, are NFL worthy.
[RAS graphic redacted, looked okay]
He played LB for the Raiders in pre-season and did very well in '24 although not well enough to make the team aside from one game. It's interesting because during the draft, there was reports that we tried to trade up for Trey Moore from Texas who was a LB/EDGE hybrid so maybe Gainer is that guy.
Trey Moore was drafted by the ‘Phins in the fourth round, and Gainer was UDFA. If Moore doesn’t make Miami’s 53 would he be an upgrade? And I didn’t realize Hall was drafted in 2022, in the second round, so he’s made it to his second contract, a two year deal. Maybe a straight up swap for Boutte would be fair value for value, or I might even throw in a sixth round sweetener at this point. Edge and LB are both positions we need to strengthen so I’d be happy to see aggressive action plus Gainer emerging as a possible contributor there.I don't know if he'll make the final roster - he was playing with the threes after all, but I hope he's a PS keeper. Played very well yesterday.
I disagree, there's still utility for young players to dress and prepare for real game-like conditions. It's also still a showcase for borderline players to earn roster spots, if not on their current team, for other teams thin at those positions.I gotta say it is time to do away with the preseason. The product is just unwatchable except for the hardcore fans who want to watch players who will probably rarely if ever make the field even if they make the roster to see who might get cut or break out.
Boutte will likely be traded before the trade deadline, probably in the couple of days after the cut to 53.Here we go round the mulberry again…
6 WR
Brown
Doubs
Douglas
Boutte
Hollins
Williams
Chism
But that’s 7, so who’s out?
Moore looked to have a serious ankle injury yesterday sadly and has apparently been doing well in pre-season up to that point.Thanks for that. I’ve noticed him a couple of times, hadn’t yet looked into his background. Appreciate the info you found and shared.
As I’ve been looking at possible players to get in a swap for Boutte I started liking Logan Hall from the Texans, because he’s listed at edge and the Texans have some depth there and also because SI reports they’re also working him at LB. So I’m interested in in seeing if we might keep Gainer since we already have him in house and from his RAS he seems athletic enough. And he’s shown up making At least a few plays on the field.
Trey Moore was drafted by the ‘Phins in the fourth round, and Gainer was UDFA. If Moore doesn’t make Miami’s 53 would he be an upgrade? And I didn’t realize Hall was drafted in 2022, in the second round, so he’s made it to his second contract, a two year deal. Maybe a straight up swap for Boutte would be fair value for value, or I might even throw in a sixth round sweetener at this point. Edge and LB are both positions we need to strengthen so I’d be happy to see aggressive action plus Gainer emerging as a possible contributor there.
OMG please just NO! Maybe get rid of Zo, put Hoyer in his place.…
What they really should do at this point is make those joint practices primetime televised events. You can have Zo and the McCourty's do play by play and color commentary too. It can't be any less watchable than the product that we saw last night even with the second half production of Morton and the offense after most people turned off the game.
Now that we replaced Wallace/Rupcich with Van Roten, the backups should be much improved. If Rizy is the replacement for Brown for a few weeks, he may need to be on the 53.Kinda. Interior OL depth was a concern but they signed Van Roten to fix that, but since he didn’t see the field, and Ben Brown is also still out, the “fix” was not apparent. So while the “2s” were out there to start the game against Philly’s second string, in reality they were playing something like their 5th and 6th best guards. In all likelihood none of the guys who played guard in this game will make the team.
Conversely, OT should be deep but one of the top backups Marcus Bryant got injured in the game and we don’t yet know the severity. So, there might be a slight issue there, although Crownover looked decent in relief and Lomu is likely the top backup OT on both sides so not an immediate issue if Bryant has to miss some time.
At center specifically, I want to say Rizy played almost the entire game and he seemed fine once again. No big issues that I saw. Probably a keeper on the PS, might be good if he can flex to a guard spot.
Possibly before? I’d think the Pats would like the trade to happen before, so they don’t have to cut a player they’d rather keep. And if it’s a swap for a player that they want on the roster they don’t risk that player ending up elsewhere.Boutte will likely be traded before the trade deadline, probably in the couple of days after the cut to 53.
Of course we will. Quite likely even after he’s traded or not traded.We will continue to debate how much to accept for Boutte and how much value he adds to the 6 WR's listed above.
From our archive - this week all-time:
August 8 - August 23 (Through 26yrs)










